Impact of Elective versus Required Medical School Research Experiences on Career Outcomes

Abstract

Many US medical schools have added a scholarly or research requirement as a potential intervention to increase the number of medical students choosing to become academic physicians and physician scientists. We designed a retrospective qualitative survey study to evaluate the impact of medical school research at the University of Alabama at Birmingham (UAB) on career choices. A survey tool was developed consisting of 74 possible questions with built-in skip patterns to customize the survey to each participant. The survey was administered using the web-based program Qualtrics to UAB School of Medicine alumni graduating between 2000 and 2014. Alumni were contacted 3 times at 2-week intervals during the year 2015, resulting in 168 completed surveys (11.5% response rate). MD/PhD graduates were excluded from the study. Most respondents completed elective research, typically for reasons relating to career advancement. 24 per cent said medical school research increased their desire for research involvement in the future, a response that positively correlated with mentorship level and publication success. Although completion of medical school research was positively correlated with current research involvement, the strongest predictor for a physician scientist career was pre-existing passion for research (p=0.008). In contrast, students motivated primarily by curricular requirement were less likely to pursue additional research opportunities. Positive medical school research experiences were associated with increased postgraduate research in our study. However, we also identified a strong relationship between current research activity and passion for research, which may predate medical school.

Medical students’ intrinsic versus extrinsic motivation to engage in research as preparation for residency

“…Hence, educators should aim to stimulate students’ intrinsic motivation. However, we can imagine that students tend to start participating in research because of extrinsic motivators, such as the belief that conducting research will secure a competitive residency spot or broaden their future career options [ 3 , 20 – 22 ]. This notion of the importance of research seems logical, as many educators emphasize the need to do something extra to students from the beginning of medical training.…”

How to Gain Expertise in Translational Research During Training

“…You have to decide if studying some or all of these disease models is appealing and exciting. A brief apprenticeship in a laboratory and communicating with other translational researchers are highly recommended to help define your passion, 3 the best predictor for a successful career in research.…”

Twelve tips to offer a short authentic and experiential individual research opportunity to a large group of undergraduate students

“…Physicians that are involved in both clinical practice and the process of conducting research are called physicianscientists. Physician-scientists have the opportunity to bridge the gap between clinical practice and research and thereby, they are crucial for making advancements within the medical field (DeLuca et al 2016;Ommering and Dekker 2017;Sklar 2017;Weaver et al 2017).…”