Impact of Cataract Surgery on Motor Vehicle Crash Involvement by Older Adults

Abstract

Context Motor vehicle crash risk in older drivers is elevated in those with cataract, a condition that impairs vision and is present in half of adults aged 65 years or older. Objective To determine the impact of cataract surgery on the crash risk for older adults in the years following surgery, compared with that of older adults who have cataract but who elect to not have surgery. Design, Setting, and Patients Prospective cohort study of 277 patients with cataract, aged 55 to 84 years at enrollment, who were recruited from 12 eye clinics in Alabama from October 1994 through March 1996, with 4 to 6 years of follow-up (to March 1999). Main Outcome Measure Police-reported motor vehicle crash occurrence involving patients who elected to have surgery compared with those who did not. Results Comparing the cataract surgery group (n=174) with the no surgery group (n=103), the rate ratio for crash involvement was 0.47 (95% confidence interval, 0.23-0.94), adjusting for race and baseline visual acuity and contrast sensitivity. The absolute rate reduction associated with cataract surgery was 4.74 crashes per million miles of travel. Conclusions In our sample, patients with cataract who underwent cataract surgery and intraocular lens implantation had half the rate of crash involvement during the follow-up period compared with cataract patients who did not undergo surgery. Cataract surgery thus may have a previously undocumented benefit for older driver safety, reducing subsequent crash rate.

The impact of cataract surgery on visual functioning, vision‐related disability and psychological distress: a randomized controlled trial

“…As expected, first eye cataract surgery had a positive effect on visual functioning. The present study confirmed previous findings that visual functioning improved for those individuals who underwent cataract surgery 10,32 , 44–46 . Vision‐related disability in older people showed significant improvement post‐surgery as expected.…”

Cataract and Pseudophakia in Elderly European Drivers

“…Backscatter is clearly largest for nuclear cataract, but very small for cortical, and intermediate for posterior subcapsular cataract (42). Contrary to a report of Owsley et al, we could not detect any significant difference between crash rates of subjects with severe bilateral cataract and bilateral pseudophakia (5). Although these 2 groups did not differ in age, driven kilometers per year, or reported difficulties during challenging driving situations, they differed significantly in visual functions and subjectively estimated speed compared to the other traffic.…”

Effectiveness of cataract surgery in reducing driving-related difficulties: a systematic review and meta-analysis

“…The external validity of observational studies is higher than for RCTs; therefore, the results of our meta-analysis may be more appropriately generalized to a wider population. Our study supports Owsley and colleagues, who demonstrated an increased risk of crashes in patients with cataracts 33. This review highlights the need for quality research that examines the relationship between cataract surgery and direct driving outcomes such as MV crashes and injury.…”