This paper seeks to engage with two key debates: how we understand 'local' with respect to the ways in which people move around local economies to buy food; and what this tells us about food planning and policies to reduce the length of the food supply chain. Using a focus group of older people in Brighton & Hove, England, the paper suggests that the social experience of food shopping is informed by individual's cultural capital, allied to the ways in which they travel around the city. In contrast, food planning is dominated by imperatives to localise the points of both production and sale, apparently with scant regard for the rather different connections between production and sale made by the shoppers themselves. The paper concludes that, for the older people in the study at least, 'local' is little more than a spatial referent along a continuum of shopping experiences. For 'local food' to gain purchase, therefore, it must be integrated into the continuum in such a way that it adds to, rather than substitutes for, existing food choices.