Identifying inequitable healthcare in older people: systematic review of current research practice

Abstract

BackgroundThere is growing consensus on the importance of identifying age-related inequities in the receipt of public health and healthcare interventions, but concerns regarding conceptual and methodological rigour in this area of research. Establishing age inequity in receipt requires evidence of a difference that is not an artefact of poor measurement of need or receipt; is not warranted on the grounds of patient preference or clinical safety; and is judged to be unfair.MethodA systematic, thematic literature review was undertaken with the objective of characterising recent research approaches. Studies were eligible if the population was in a country within the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development and analyses included an explicit focus on age-related patterns of healthcare receipt including those 60 years or older. A structured extraction template was applied. Extracted material was synthesised in thematic memos. A set of categorical codes were then defined and applied to produce summary counts across key dimensions. This process was iterative to allow reconciliation of discrepancies and ensure reliability.ResultsForty nine studies met the eligibility criteria. A wide variety of concepts, terms and methodologies were used across these studies. Thirty five studies employed multivariable techniques to produce adjusted receipt-need ratios, though few clearly articulated their rationale, indicating the need for great conceptual clarity. Eighteen studies made reference to patient preference as a relevant consideration, but just one incorporated any kind of adjustment for this factor. Twenty five studies discussed effectiveness among older adults, with fourteen raising the possibility of differential effectiveness, and one differential cost-effectiveness, by age. Just three studies made explicit reference to the ethical nature of healthcare resource allocation by age. While many authors presented suitably cautious conclusions, some appeared to over-stretch their findings concluding that observed differences were ‘inequitable’. Limitations include possible biases in the retrieved material due to inconsistent database indexing and a focus on OECD country populations and studies with English titles.ConclusionsCaution is needed among clinicians and other evidence-users in accepting claims of healthcare ‘ageism’ in some published papers. Principles for improved research practice are proposed.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12939-017-0605-z) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Primary Care Attributes in Traditional Unities and With Family Health Strategy, an Oldest-Old Patients Perspective

“…The study by Araújo et al (2014) evaluated the quality of PHC in FHS in a city in Northeastern Brazil from the perspective of the elderly and identified that the units studied had a high degree of orientation for the component Use of the First Contact Access attribute and low degree for the Accessibility component of this same attribute, corroborating the findings of this study. Salway et al (2017) verified in their study that the elderly access is unequal. Higher income and education were associated with the use and access to consultations (ZANESCO et al, 2018).…”

Analysis of variation in pre-procedural fasting duration for common inpatient gastrointestinal procedures

“…However, since language proficiency and other variables such as nursing staffing ratio and communication modality were not available, this relationship cannot be established. The relationship between increasing age and longer NPO duration may also be a manifestation of established disparities described in the care of the elderly ( 21 , 22 ), though the absolute differences in times across the age spectrum are still relatively small. The inverse relationship with hospital occupancy may reflect a heightened urgency to get patients treated sooner to reduce a backlog of cases.…”

Acesso à Atenção Primária à Saúde de longevos: perspectiva de profissionais da Saúde da Família de um município do Rio Grande do Sul

“…Há poucos estudos que exploram o acesso dos longevos aos serviços de saúde e que, em muitos casos, esse acesso é desigual 19 . Maior renda e escolaridade estiveram associadas à utilização e acesso a consultas 20 .…”