Identification of and Spatio-Temporal Differences between Microbial Assemblages from Two Neighboring Sulfurous Lakes: Comparison by Microscopy and Denaturing Gradient Gel Electrophoresis

Abstract

The microbial assemblages of Lake Cisó and Lake Vilar (Banyoles, northeast Spain) were analyzed in space and time by microscopy and by performing PCR-denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) and sequence analysis of 16S rRNA gene fragments. Samples obtained from different water depths and at two different times of the year (in the winter during holomixis and in the early spring during a phytoplankton bloom) were analyzed. Although the lakes have the same climatic conditions and the same water source, the limnological parameters were different, as were most of the morphologically distinguishable photosynthetic bacteria enumerated by microscopy. The phylogenetic affiliations of the predominant DGGE bands were inferred by performing a comparative 16S rRNA sequence analysis. Sequences obtained from Lake Cisó samples were related to gram-positive bacteria and to members of the division Proteobacteria. Sequences obtained from Lake Vilar samples were related to members of the Cytophaga-Flavobacterium-Bacteroides phylum and to cyanobacteria. Thus, we found that like the previously reported differences between morphologically distinct inhabitants of the two lakes, there were also differences among the community members whose morphologies did not differ conspicuously. The changes in the species composition from winter to spring were also marked. The two lakes both contained sequences belonging to phototrophic green sulfur bacteria, which is consistent with microscopic observations, but these sequences were different from the sequences of cultured strains previously isolated from the lakes. Euryarchaeal sequences (i.e., methanogen-and thermoplasmarelated sequences) also were present in both lakes. These euryarchaeal group sequences dominated the archaeal sequences in Lake Cisó but not in Lake Vilar. In Lake Vilar, a new planktonic population related to the crenarchaeota produced the dominant archaeal band. The phylogenetic analysis indicated that new bacterial and archaeal lineages were present and that the microbial diversity of these assemblages was greater than previously known. We evaluated the correspondence between the abundances of several morphotypes and DGGE bands by comparing microscopy and sequencing results. Our data provide evidence that the sequences obtained from the DGGE fingerprints correspond to the microorganisms that are actually present at higher concentrations in the natural system. Identification and quantification of organisms, which provide the key parameters in diversity studies, are routinely performed operations in macroecology but are still difficult tasks in microbial ecology (5, 38). Measurements of bacterial metabolic processes yield valuable ecological information but, most of the time, give no clue as to which species are involved (15). As a result, our knowledge of the taxonomic compositions of microbial communities and of the factors which control the abundance and distribution of microbial populations is extremely limited.Over the last 10 years several molecular techniques have be...

Plankton community composition in the Three Gorges Reservoir Region revealed by PCR-DGGE and its relationships with environmental factors

“…Euclidean distance was used to calculate the dissimilarity in the physico-chemical analysis, and dissimilarity was calculated using the Jaccard's coefficient in the other two dendrograms. ( Casamayor et al, 2000Casamayor et al, , 2002. A large number of OTUs (46.7% of the bacterial and 64.1% of the eukaryotic OTUs) identified herein were present in less than half of the sampling sites, whereas, less than 5% of the total OTUs were common to all the samples.…”

Disconnect of microbial structure and function: enzyme activities and bacterial communities in nascent stream corridors

“…DGGE tends to detect dominant taxa only, resulting in a greatly simplified blueprint of the communities characterized with this kind of fingerprinting methods (Casamayor et al, 2000;Lindströ m, 2000;Woodcock et al, 2006). This explanation would imply, however, that patterns of ecosystem functioning (that is, potential enzyme activities) are primarily driven by subordinate as opposed to the dominant species or strains that are best detected by DGGE.…”

Seasonal patterns of viral, microbial and planktonic communities in Sidi Salem: a freshwater reservoir (North of Tunisia)

“…Bacterial production and chlorophyll a measurements were shown to be significantly higher in the eutrophic basin of Lake Erie, Ohio, USA, than in the less productive basins (DeBruyn et al, 2004). The fluctuation of vertical distributions of heterotrophic bacteria during the study period, explained that the bacterial community composition varied in response to environmental parameters' changing, also with their different adaptations proliferating under a range of light conditions (Casamayor et al, 2000;Vila and Abella, 2001). Furthermore, it is generally accepted that phytoplankton, especially picofractioned phytoplankton, are the principal source of organic carbon for bacteria (Baines and Pace, 1991).…”