Healthcare worker intentions to receive a COVID-19 vaccine and reasons for hesitancy: A survey of 16,158 health system employees on the eve of vaccine distribution

Abstract

Healthcare workers (HCWs) have been recommended to receive first priority for limited COVID-19 vaccines. They have also been identified as potential ambassadors of COVID-19 vaccine acceptance, helping to ensure that sufficient members of a hesitant public accept COVID-19 vaccines to achieve population immunity. Yet HCWs themselves have shown vaccine hesitancy in other contexts and the few prior surveys of U.S. HCW intentions to receive a COVID-19 vaccine report acceptance rates of only 28% to 34%. However, it is unknown whether HCW acceptance remains low following mid-November announcements of the efficacy of the first COVID-19 vaccines and the issuance of two emergency use authorizations (EUA) in December. We report the results of a December 2020 survey (N = 16,158; response rate 61%) administered by a large Pennsylvania health system to determine the intentions of its employees to receive a vaccine when it is offered to them. In a mixed sample of individuals serving in patient-facing and other roles, 55% would decide to receive a COVID-19 vaccine when offered, 16.4% would not, and 28.5% reported being undecided. The distribution of responses varied little across hospital campuses, between those in patient-facing roles and other HCWs, or by area or department of work. The higher rate of COVID-19 vaccine acceptance we observe may reflect the framing and timing of our survey. Among hesitant respondents, an overwhelming majority (90.3%) reported concerns about unknown risks and insufficient data. Other commonly reported concerns included known side effects (57.4%) and wanting to wait until they see how it goes with others (44.4%). We observed a substantial increase in self-reported intent to receive a COVID-19 vaccine after an FDA advisory committee voted to recommend an EUA. Among respondents who completed the survey after that point in time, 79% intend to receive a COVID-19 vaccine (n = 1155). Although only suggestive, this trend offers hope that rates of COVID-19 vaccine acceptance may be higher among HCWs and, perhaps, the general public than more hypothetical survey results have indicated.

COVID-19 vaccination intentions amongst care-professionals in the field of intellectual disability: a scoping review

“…The second event was the release of phase III clinical trial results by two vaccine manufacturers, after which both vaccines were approved for Emergency Use Authorization (EUA). Similar results were found by Meyer et al (2020): an increase in daily recorded cases of vaccine willingness was reported after the EUA release.…”

COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy in underserved communities of North Carolina

“…Repeated polls report that vaccine hesitancy has dropped over time (yet remains higher among Blacks) [ 25 , 31 ]. Surveys of health care workers reported more hesitancy (than the public) at the beginning of the pandemic, but as the results from clinical trials were released, hesitancy diminished precipitously [ 36 , 37 ]. Despite these promising trends, vaccine hesitancy may persist among historically marginalized populations unless substantial resources, funding, messaging, public health activities, and access to vaccination programs are deployed and evaluated.…”

COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy in Underserved Communities of North Carolina

“…31,39 Surveys of health care workers reported more hesitancy (than the public) at the beginning of the pandemic, but as the results from clinical trials were released, hesitancy diminished precipitously. 40,41…”