“… Author, year | Method | Inclusion criteria | Number of patients | Basic treatment | Traditional Chinese Medicine | Outcome | Gender (Male/Female) | Age (years) | Comorbidity | Initial symptoms |
Jie Zhao, 2020 [ 58 ] | Randomized controlled trial | Patients with severe COVID-19 | 39 (WM group 24, TCM and WM group 15) | Bed rest and adjuvant therapy; ensure adequate calorie and water intake; maintain water and electrolyte balance and homeostasis and strengthen psychological treatment for older children when necessary. | Yidu-toxicity blocking lung decoction (Bitter almonds, raw gypsum, trichosanthes, raw rhubarb, raw ephedra, roasted ephedra, Tinglizi, peach kernel, grass fruit, betel nut, atractylodes), 2 weeks | White blood cell count, neutrophil count, lymphocyte count, IL-6, IL-8, IL-2R, TNF-α, C-reactive protein, immune function, cure rate, length of hospital stays | 22/17 | – | – | Fever (94.87 %); dry cough (79.49 %) |
Jiaxing Tian, 2020 [ 60 ] | Retrospective cohort trial | Mild, moderate COVID-19, HSYF in the exposed group used for more than 2 days | 721 (exposed group 430, non-exposed group 291) | Treatment Guideline for COVID-19 released by the National Health Commission of the People’s Republic of China | HSYF (Ephedra, Gypsum, Almond, Qianghuo, Tinglizi, Guanzhong, Earth Dragon, Xu Changqing, Huoxiang, Peilan, Cangzhu, Yunling, Raw Atractylodes, Jiao Hawthorn, Jiao Shenqu, Jiao Malt, Magnolia, Jiao Betel Nut, Simmering Grass Fruit, ginger) | Proportion of mild and moderate COVID-19 patients who progressed to severe disease | 347/374 | 48 | Hypertension (16.9 %), fatty liver (7.9 %), diabetes (7.1 %) | Fever (51.2 %), cough (27.6 %), diarrhea (20.8 %), fatigue (19.0%) |
Mingzhong Xiao, 2020 [ 56 ] | Randomized controlled trial | Suspicious and confirmed COVID-19 cases; 18−85 years old, regardless of gender; provide informed consent | 283 (LHQWC 94, HXZQG + LHQC 95, WM 94) | |
…”