Global analysis of seagrass restoration: the importance of large‐scale planting

Abstract

Summary1. In coastal and estuarine systems, foundation species like seagrasses, mangroves, saltmarshes or corals provide important ecosystem services. Seagrasses are globally declining and their reintroduction has been shown to restore ecosystem functions. However, seagrass restoration is often challenging, given the dynamic and stressful environment that seagrasses often grow in. 2. From our world-wide meta-analysis of seagrass restoration trials (1786 trials), we describe general features and best practice for seagrass restoration. We confirm that removal of threats is important prior to replanting. Reduced water quality (mainly eutrophication), and construction activities led to poorer restoration success than, for instance, dredging, local direct impact and natural causes. Proximity to and recovery of donor beds were positively corre- The meta-analysis shows that both trial survival and seagrass population growth rate in trials that survived are positively affected by the number of plants or seeds initially transplanted. This relationship between restoration scale and restoration success was not related to trial characteristics of the initial restoration. The majority of the seagrass restoration trials have been very small, which may explain the low overall trial survival rate (i.e. estimated 37%). 4. Successful regrowth of the foundation seagrass species appears to require crossing a minimum threshold of reintroduced individuals. Our study provides the first global field evidence for the requirement of a critical mass for recovery, which may also hold for other foundation species showing strong positive feedback to a dynamic environment. 5. Synthesis and applications. For effective restoration of seagrass foundation species in its typically dynamic, stressful environment, introduction of large numbers is seen to be beneficial and probably serves two purposes. First, a large-scale planting increases trial survival -large numbers ensure the spread of risks, which is needed to overcome high natural variability. Secondly, a large-scale trial increases population growth rate by enhancing selfsustaining feedback, which is generally found in foundation species in stressful environments such as seagrass beds. Thus, by careful site selection and applying appropriate techniques, spreading of risks and enhancing self-sustaining feedback in concert increase success of seagrass restoration.

Seed Predation by the Shore Crab Carcinus maenas: A Positive Feedback Preventing Eelgrass Recovery?

“…In addition, planting a high number of seeds over large spatial scales may also increase the chances of survival by temporarily overwhelm seed predators. This is partly supported by a recent review of restoration studies that found higher survival and growth of plants when a higher number of shoots/seeds were planted [62]. …”

Strategies to enhance the resilience of the world's seagrass meadows

“…Seagrass restoration projects globally have had variable levels of success (van Katwijk et al . ). Restoration efforts need to be better informed to maximize benefits and avoid misplaced action, and guidance is required to strategically direct restoration activity (van Katwijk et al .…”

The importance of phenotypic plasticity and local adaptation in driving intraspecific variability in thermal niches of marine macrophytes

“…With regards to marine macrophytes, the concept of assisted migration is not new. Reforestation of seagrass meadows, which are experiencing widespread global habitat loss from a multitude of stressors (Orth et al 2006), has been attempted many times, although only ~37% of restorations have been successful (Katwijk et al 2016). Examples from seaweeds are distinctly lacking which may be due to the inherent logistical challenges associated with transplanting and maintaining seaweeds on rocky reefs, often in highly dynamic environments.…”