Genetic Prediction Models and Heritability Estimates for Functional Longevity in Dairy Cattle

Abstract

Longevity is a major component of the breeding objective for dairy cattle in many countries because of its high economic value. The trait has been recommended for inclusion in the breeding objective for dairy cattle in South Africa. Linear models, random regression (RR) models, threshold models (TMs) and proportional hazard models (PH) have been used to evaluate longevity. This paper discusses these methodologies and their advantages and disadvantages. Heritability estimates obtained from these models are also reviewed. Linear methodologies can model binary and actual longevity, while RR and TM methodologies model binary survival. PH procedures model the hazard function of a cow at time t derived from survival from first calving to culling, death or censoring. It is difficult to compare methodologies for sire evaluation and ranking across countries because of the variation in the definition of longevity and the choice of model. Sire estimated breeding values (EBVs) are derived differently for the models. Sire EBVs from PH models are expressed as deviations of the culling risk from the mean of the base sires, expected percentage of daughters still alive after a given number of lactations, expected length of productive life in absolute terms or as standard deviation units. In linear, TM and RR modelling, sire EBVs for longevity have been expressed as deviations of survival from the mean estimated with Best Linear Unbiased Prediction (BLUP). Appropriate models should thus be developed to evaluate functional longevity for possible inclusion in the overall breeding objective for South African dairy cattle. ______________________________________________________________________________________

Genetic evaluation for functional longevity in Polish Simmental cattle

“…The different trait definitions (e.g. total lifetime, true productive life, functional productive life, number of parities, lifetime days in milk, survival to fixed age) and the different methods used in genetic evaluation of longevity doi: 10.17221/87/2016-CJAS based on linear, random regression, threshold, or proportional hazards (PH) models produce a wide range of heritability estimates (0.01-0.22); linear models yield lower estimates (0.01-0.10) (Sasaki 2013;Imbayarwo-Chikosi et al 2015). Survival analysis, which provides a better description of longevity data than other models do, leads to more complete extraction of genetic variance and thus higher heritability estimates (Vukasinovic et al 1999).…”

Analysis of Longevity Traits in Holstein Cattle: A Review

“…Typically, these models include linear models ( Allaire, 1976 ), threshold models ( Boettcher et al, 1999 ), random regression models ( Pelt et al, 2015 ), sire models ( Brotherstone et al, 1997 ), and survival analysis ( Buenger et al, 2001 ). Linear models, threshold models, and random regression models can process multiple traits simultaneously; thereby directly estimate the genetic correlation between longevity and other traits with a relatively fast calculation speed ( Imbayarwo-Chikosi et al, 2015 ). Survival analysis can appropriately accommodate censored data, consider time-dependent environmental impact, and manage the skewed distribution of longevity characteristics ( Imbayarwo-Chikosi et al, 2016 ).…”

Assessment of Genetic and Health Management of Tunisian Holstein Dairy Herds with a Focus on Longevity

“…Due to its high economic value, longevity is an important part of dairy cattle breeding goals in many countries. Imbayarwo-Chikosi et al [ 21 ] attribute the high economic value of longevity to the herd trait dynamics that depend on the degree of voluntary and involuntary selection. Reducing involuntary culling increases the chances of voluntary culling and keeping high-yielding cows for longer [ 21 ].…”