Freshwater management policies in New Zealand

Abstract

1. This paper examines the effectiveness of New Zealand's Resource Management Act in managing freshwater resources. 2. A distinctive feature of the New Zealand situation is the extent to which Parliament has delegated the sustainable management of freshwater resources to catchment based regional councils. Regional councils exercise a pivotal role in water resource planning but without much guidance or technical assistance from central government. 3. Contrary to New Zealand's ‘clean green’ image, water pollution is alarmingly high in relation to its small population size. The Act puts particular emphasis on improving water quality by empowering regional councils to address this concern in policy statements and plans. 4. Water allocation policies in New Zealand are dominated by a supply‐oriented biophysical perspective based on prescribing minimum flows and maximum extraction thresholds to safeguard the life‐supporting capacity of ecosystems. Despite persistent attempts by central government to encourage regional councils to adopt competitive tendering and tradable permits for allocating water, most regional councils favour allocation procedures based on community consultation and political compromise. 5. Water Conservation Orders are a special provision in the Act for protecting outstanding amenity or intrinsic values of waters in their natural state. However, no new applications have been made under the RMA since 1991. 6. The RMA has brought about significant procedural improvements in water resource planning, by means of a cooperative, consultative approach. However, limited attention has been given to issues of water allocation to promote the sustainable use of increasingly scarce resources. The policies and rules in recently notified plans now regulate point source as well as non‐point source discharges. Nevertheless, central government may need to reassess its role if it wishes to achieve a significant improvement in water quality and there needs to be greater coordination of water resource monitoring systems operated by regional councils to provide a national overview. ©1997 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Maximizing water yield with indigenous non-forest vegetation: a New Zealand perspective

“…An integrated approach to land‐use planning, evaluating ecosystem services, recognizing trade‐offs, and incorporating the need to protect water supply and quality is needed (Prato 1999; de Groot 2006) in New Zealand (Memon 1997) and elsewhere (Farley et al . 2005).…”

“…This mainly reflected concerns about land stability and erosion. Although the importance of guaranteed water supply and quality was appreciated, the record of integrated management is patchy, with many substantial challenges still to be faced (Memon 1997; Memon and Selsky 2004).…”

“…Under New Zealand's Resource Management Act of 1991, regional councils must seek to protect and enhance the environment, and safeguarding water supply and quality is an important component of these responsibilities (Memon 1997). Councils can develop regional water plans to establish objectives and criteria for water management (Snelder and Hughey 2005).…”

Reregulating for Freshwater Enclosure: A State of Exception in Canterbury, Aotearoa New Zealand

“…Freedom to do what you like with your own land then becomes a principle of the Act, provided the effects of those activities are minor, which tends to be loosely interpreted. In practice, the privileging of property rights and the inability to deal with cumulative effects under the Act (Cocklin and Furuseth ) has contributed to a decline in many indicators of environmental health, particularly in relation to freshwater in some regions (Memon ; Ministry for the Environment ). Memon and Weber () argue that within the neoliberalised political terrain central government has failed to offer the support and guidance needed to move beyond an effects‐based focus, to more integrated approaches to environmental management.…”

The Environmental Effects of New Zealand’s Free-Market Reforms

“…Dairy farming also exerts pressure on water supply largely through demand for irrigation, however this issue is not considered in this paper (but see Cocklin and Blunden, 1998;Meredith, 1999;Memon, 2000;Collins et al, 2001;MAF, 2002c). Sources of waste are characterised as point source and non-point source in origin.…”