Formative vs. summative assessment: impacts on academic motivation, attitude toward learning, test anxiety, and self-regulation skill

Abstract

As assessment plays an important role in the process of teaching and learning, this research explored the impacts of formative and summative assessments on academic motivation, attitude toward learning, test anxiety, and self-regulation skill of EFL students in Iran. To fulfill the objectives of this research, 72 Iranian EFL learners were chosen based on the convenience sampling method assigned to two experimental groups (summative group and formative group) and a control group. Then, the groups took the pre-tests of test anxiety, motivation, and self-regulation skill. Then, one experimental group was trained by following the rules of the formative assessment and the other experimental group was taught according to the summative assessment. The control group was instructed without using any preplanned assessment. After a 15-session treatment, the post-tests of the test anxiety, motivation, and self-regulation skill were administered to all groups to assess the impacts of the instruction on their language achievement. Lastly, a questionnaire of attitude was administered to both experimental groups to examine their attitudes towards the impacts of formative and summative assessment on their English learning improvement. The outcomes of one-way ANOVA and Bonferroni tests revealed that both summative and formative assessments were effective but the formative one was more effective on academic motivation, test anxiety, and self-regulation skill. The findings of one sample t-test indicated that the participants had positive attitudes towards summative and formative assessments. Based on the results, it can be concluded that formative assessment is an essential part of teaching that should be used in EFL instructional contexts. The implications of this study can help students to detect their own weaknesses and target areas that need more effort and work.

Expectation and Satisfaction Level of Students with Impact of Formative Assessment on the Scores of Summative Assessments in the Subject of Dental Materials -A Study from Private Dental College Karachi Pakistan

“…The finding of the current study is in agreement with Evans et al that formative assessments are the best way of improving scores in summative exams. 15 In the current study, most of the students considered that formative assessment helps them to recognize their learning gaps so that they can work on these areas for improvement. They also sensed that formative assessment encourages in-depth learning and retention of concepts for a longer period.…”

Exploring student teachers’ perceptions of assessment ethics across university-based teacher education programs in Iran

“…Furthermore, regarding university assessment, it is quite commonplace that the educational system in Iran does not encourage peer work, and due to their inadequate knowledge of assessment, students themselves think that they cannot be fair in assessing their classmates (Ahmadi, 2021 ). Given the usefulness of adopting formative assessments to enhance EFL students’ “academic motivation, attitude toward learning, test anxiety, and self-regulation” (Ismail et al, 2022 ) in Iran, teacher educators are recommended to instil formative assessment in their pedagogical practices (p.19). Internationally, this finding may reflect that of Yan (Yan and Cheng, 2015 ), who proclaims that students’ ideologies and identities have been shaped by examination culture in a way that may lead to students’ resistance to change.…”

Avaliação formativa como estratégia na metodologia ativa no curso de medicina: uma revisão integrativa

“…No que se trata das principais desvantagens, é necessário citar a resistência dos alunos na auto avaliação e também a pouco experiência dos docentes que tem dificuldade em aplicar esse método de ensino (Suárez et al, 2020). Ismail et al, (2022) revelaram que as avaliações formativas e somativas são eficazes, entretanto a formativa apresentase mais eficiente no âmbito da formação acadêmica, no que se refere à ansiedade em teste e em habilidades de autorregulação, sendo necessária no processo de ensino-aprendizagem por intermédio do processo de feedback que auxilia os discentes a visualizarem suas dificuldades para posteriormente direcionar maior esforço e trabalho para o avanço educacional. Stenberg, Mangrio, Bengtsson & Carlson (2018) notaram que a comunicação e a colaboração fornecidas no contexto social da avaliação formativa pelo feedback em pares são de suma importância durante a formação de um profissional de saúde, pois essas competências são aderidas na prática de prestação de cuidados ao paciente e expansão de conhecimentos dos discentes.…”