The electrosynthesis of ammonia from nitrogen and water is a topic of considerable interest in the quest for sustainable and decentralized NH 3 production. Tin(II) phthalocyanine complexes have been proposed as electrocatalysts for nitrogen reduction to ammonia in aqueous solution, with Faradaic yields approaching 2% having been reported. Herein, however, we show that such complexes are not electrocatalysts for this transformation, with the amount of ammonia detected being essentially the same under N 2 and under Ar. Instead, we suggest that apparent ammonia generation could arise either through contaminants in the as-prepared tin(II) phthalocyanine complexes, or by the electro-decomposition of these complexes under cathodic bias.