Flexibility decision pathways in the management of uncertainty in property development: experience from an emerging market

Abstract

Purpose This paper aims to investigate the flexible decision pathways adopted by development advisors in the management of uncertainty in property development. Specifically, the study examines the quantitative techniques adopted by development advisors, the level of adoption of real options analysis (ROA) vis-à-vis the level of adoption of heuristics. Finally, the types of options exercised in property development were analysed. This was with a view to providing information that could mitigate the challenges of risk and uncertainty and increasing investment failure associated with property development in Nigeria, an emerging market. Design/methodology/approach The study adopted a survey method and was conducted on development advisors in property development companies/estate surveying and valuation firms in Nigeria. A total of 195 development advisors participated in the survey. The respondents were required to rate, on a five-point Likert scale, the level of adoption of the quantitative models, heuristics and the types of flexibility exercised during development. The data were analysed using mean rating, one-sample t-test and analysis of variance. Findings The results revealed that there was a preference for the use of traditional techniques, while probabilistic appraisal models and other contemporary methods such as ROA are seldom adopted by development advisors. While there was a significantly high level of adoption of heuristics, the stratified analysis examining the profile of the respondents and the level of adoption of ROA and heuristics suggests that years of experience influenced the level of adoption of both the ROA and heuristics by the development advisors. The analysis of the types of flexibility showed that staging/phasing and changing the initial use/design were the most prevalent flexibility pathways adopted during the development. However, the study found that there was no significant difference concerning the choice of flexibility being adopted by development advisors who used ROA and those who did not. Practical implications The study provides an understanding of the decision pathways adopted by development advisors in an emerging market like Nigeria. Originality/value The paper contributes to studies on decision-making pathways in the management of uncertainty under dynamic conditions by development advisors in emerging markets.

Portfolio Diversification of Nigerian REIT: Evidence from an African Real Estate Market

“…Hoesli (2002) noted that the performance of real estate assets, either as an independent asset or in a portfolio mix, will be of concern to investors. This concern becomes more compelling in emerging economies as emerging markets are bedeviled with a high rate of fluctuations and volatilities as opposed to the developed markets with somewhat stable and predictable macroeconomic indices (Ayodele & Olaleye, 2021). Thus, understanding the investment performance and diversification benefit of indirect real estate assets becomes germane to all categories of real estate investors.…”

Real options analysis applied to investment projects in planted forests of Pinus

“…Thus, the deferral option allows delaying the beginning or each stage of an investment project. By waiting for new information associated with the investment project or market environment, it is possible to add value by providing the right strategic path to investors (Ayodele and Olaleye, 2021).…”