Finite-Element Modeling of Bones From CT Data: Sensitivity to Geometry and Material Uncertainties

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to analyze how the uncertainties in modelling the geometry and the material properties of a human bone affect the predictions of a finite-element model derived from computed tomography (CT) data. A sensitivity analysis, based on a Monte Carlo method, was performed using three femur models generated from in vivo CT datasets, each subjected to two different loading conditions. The geometry, the density and the mechanical properties of the bone tissue were considered as random input variables. Finite-element results typically used in biomechanics research were considered as statistical output variables, and their sensitivity to the inputs variability assessed. The results showed that it is not possible to define a priori the influence of the errors related to the geometry definition process and to the material assignment process on the finite-element analysis results. The errors in the geometric representation of the bone are always the dominant variables for the stresses, as was expected. However, for all the variables, the results seemed to be dependent on the loading condition and to vary from subject to subject. The most interesting result is, however, that using the proposed method to build a finite-element model of a femur from a CT dataset of the quality typically achievable in the clinical practice, the coefficients of variation of the output variables never exceed the 9%. The presented method is hence robust enough to be used for investigating the mechanical behavior of bones with subject-specific finite-element models derived from CT data taken in vivo.

Left Atrial Wall Stress Distribution and Its Relationship to Electrophysiologic Remodeling in Persistent Atrial Fibrillation

“…Although the accuracy of the geometry is the most important factor when simulating wall stress, 26 the wall thickness and the transmural pressure gradient are also very important. Hence, the impact of varying these parameters on wall stress distribution was explored.…”

Association Between Aneurysm Shoulder Stress and Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Expansion

“…image-based finite element analysis modeling has been studied previously. 38,39 It has been demonstrated that the coefficients of variation of the output variables from finite element analysis modeling never exceed 9%. Further improvement in CT image resolution and automatic image processing techniques will certainly reduce the uncertainties in the patientspecific modeling in the future.…”

A review of probabilistic analysis in orthopaedic biomechanics

“…Laz et al included uncertainty in the density-to-modulus and density-to-strength relationships used in assigning bone material properties and predicted large amounts of variability in stress and risk in a proximal femur [35]. Monte Carlo and Latin hypercube approaches were implemented by Taddei et al to evaluate the impact of uncertainty in geometry, density, and material properties of the bone tissue on bone displacement stresses and strains under compression and torsion loading [36]. Using correlation coefficients, the study reported that scaling of the geometry had the greatest impact on the performance measures.…”