Exploring Impacts of Rapid-Scan Radar Data on NWS Warning Decisions

Abstract

Rapid-scan weather radars, such as the S-band phased array radar at the National Weather Radar Testbed in Norman, Oklahoma, improve precision in the depiction of severe storm processes. To explore potential impacts of such data on forecaster warning decision making, 12 National Weather Service forecasters participated in a preliminary study with two control conditions: 1) when radar scan time was similar to volume coverage pattern 12 (4.5 min) and 2) when radar scan time was faster (43 s). Under these control conditions, forecasters were paired and worked a tropical tornadic supercell case. Their decision processes were observed and audio was recorded, interactions with data displays were video recorded, and the products were archived. A debriefing was conducted with each of the six teams independently and jointly, to ascertain the forecaster decision-making process. Analysis of these data revealed that teams examining the same data sometimes came to different conclusions about whether and when to warn. Six factors contributing toward these differences were identified: 1) experience, 2) conceptual models, 3) confidence, 4) tolerance of possibly missing a tornado occurrence, 5) perceived threats, and 6) software issues. The three 43-s teams issued six warnings: three verified, two did not verify, and one event was missed. Warning lead times were the following: tornado, 18.6 and 11.5 min, and severe, 6 min. The three tornado warnings issued by the three 4.5-min teams verified, though warning lead times were shorter: 4.6 and 0 min (two teams). In this case, use of rapid-scan data showed the potential to extend warning lead time and improve forecasters’ confidence, compared to standard operations.

Creation and Communication of Hurricane Risk Information

“…2). They characterize the threat by applying their expertise to analyze and synthesize information from multiple sources (Lindell et al 2007;Morss and Ralph 2007;Heinselman et al 2012). They then convey this threat by regularly generating and issuing a suite of products, including textual forecasts, track forecast cone graphics, wind speed probabilities, and tropical storm and hurricane watches and warnings.…”

Evaluation of Data Display Methods in a Flash Flood Prediction Tool

“…This pattern matching technique is indicative of the representativeness heuristic, which can lead to errors if similar data sets are applied incorrectly to weather events. In a further example of this, Heinselman, LaDue, and Lazrus [5] found that a forecaster's prior experiences with a particular type of weather event affected the forecaster's ability to predict a similar weather event.…”

Adaptive Beamspace Processing for Phased-Array Weather Radars

“…With the development of phased-array technology, the next generation of weather radars is likely to be multifunction phased-array radars (MPARs) supporting both aircraft and weather surveillance missions [1]- [3]. One potential advantage of a phased-array weather radar is that it can meet the constant demand for faster update times, which can increase warning lead times and improve forecasters' confidence [4]. High-temporal-resolution observations can also lead to better scientific understanding of rapidly evolving weather phenomena [5].…”