1.The oscillations in the mass spectra of metal clusters may be caused by both the shell structure of electronic spectra and the positioning of ions in lattice sites [1]. Experiments show that the oscillations in the mass spectra of large aluminum Al N [2][3][4] and sodium Na N [5] clusters ( N is the number of atoms in a cluster) differ significantly in shape. Whereas the oscillations for sodium proceed with beats, the aluminum clusters with N > 250 exhibit sinusoidal behavior with a frequency approximately twice that for sodium. The spectra of the Al N clusters of smaller sizes represent an intricate pattern without any distinct period. In the literature, the cause of this distinction is discussed in terms of classical trajectories of electron motion in a self-consistent potential (the number of electrons in a cluster is N e = wN , where w is the valence of a metal).In [3], an attempt was undertaken to explain the experiment by invoking a spherical jellium model and the quasiclassical theory [6][7][8][9]. It was conjectured that, contrary to a hard potential of Na N clusters, in which a triangular trajectory and a square trajectory of a close frequency dominate (the oscillations with beats result from the interference of the relevant contributions), in a soft potential of Al N clusters with 250 < N < 900, the main contribution comes from a single trajectory shaped like a five-pointed star. According to this theory, the clusters of larger size should have triangular and, later, square trajectories (this is confirmed by the selfconsistent computation [2] of the density of states for N e = 4940), leading to a change in the oscillation frequency.An alternative explanation was suggested in [4], where the mass spectra of "cold" ( T = 100 K) Al N clusters were experimentally measured and analyzed over a very wide range of N values (250 < N < 10000). An analysis of the spectra showed that the oscillation maxima, numbered sequentially by the index k ( k > 25), appeared with a constant frequency over the entire range studied and fitted the law N Ӎ 0.0104 k 3 , which is readily explained by the atomic positioning in an octahedral lattice. Accordingly, the cluster shape is not a sphere but an octahedron, so that the shell filling corresponds to the assembling of one of its faces. Evidently, the spherical jellium model with uniformly distributed ions inside the sphere is not adequate in this case.In [10], the assumption about the dominant contribution from a five-point-star orbit in the aluminum clusters was ruled out by the quantum-mechanical calculation of the density of states for N e = 1000 electrons in the Saxon-Woods potential.Nevertheless, the positions of the maxima observed in [2] for 250 < N < 430 at T = 295 K agree well with the results of self-consistent calculations carried out in the same work with the jellium model, while the comparison of the mass spectra of Al N observed at T = 110 K and T = 295 K for N < 250 reveals that the temperature has an appreciable effect on the shapes of the corresponding curves, ...