Evaluating Strategies to Normalise Biological Replicates of Western Blot Data

Abstract

Western blot data are widely used in quantitative applications such as statistical testing and mathematical modelling. To ensure accurate quantitation and comparability between experiments, Western blot replicates must be normalised, but it is unclear how the available methods affect statistical properties of the data. Here we evaluate three commonly used normalisation strategies: (i) by fixed normalisation point or control; (ii) by sum of all data points in a replicate; and (iii) by optimal alignment of the replicates. We consider how these different strategies affect the coefficient of variation (CV) and the results of hypothesis testing with the normalised data. Normalisation by fixed point tends to increase the mean CV of normalised data in a manner that naturally depends on the choice of the normalisation point. Thus, in the context of hypothesis testing, normalisation by fixed point reduces false positives and increases false negatives. Analysis of published experimental data shows that choosing normalisation points with low quantified intensities results in a high normalised data CV and should thus be avoided. Normalisation by sum or by optimal alignment redistributes the raw data uncertainty in a mean-dependent manner, reducing the CV of high intensity points and increasing the CV of low intensity points. This causes the effect of normalisations by sum or optimal alignment on hypothesis testing to depend on the mean of the data tested; for high intensity points, false positives are increased and false negatives are decreased, while for low intensity points, false positives are decreased and false negatives are increased. These results will aid users of Western blotting to choose a suitable normalisation strategy and also understand the implications of this normalisation for subsequent hypothesis testing.

Hydrogen sulfide decreases β-adrenergic agonist-stimulated lung liquid clearance by inhibiting ENaC-mediated transepithelial sodium absorption

“…Lung liquid clearance data were analyzed with Student's paired or unpaired t-test (two-tailed). Densitometric data from Western blot experiments were analyzed by Student's unpaired t-test, since this test is robust with respect to a theoretical log-normal distribution of Western blot data (20). P values Յ 0.05 are considered statistically significant and are indicated by an asterisk.…”

ZDHHC3 Tyrosine Phosphorylation Regulates Neural Cell Adhesion Molecule Palmitoylation

“…Since the control and experimental groups in a single experiment were from the same cell passage (in biochemical experiments) or from cells prepared from the same animal (in the case of hippocampal neurons used for morphometric analysis), we used repeated-measures (RM) or paired tests to determine statistical significance. To analyze Western blot data for FGF2-mediated ZDHHC3 phosphorylation in N2a cells, as well as the level of NCAM palmitoylation in vivo, normalization by the sum of the replicate method was applied (48). Statistical significance was determined by two-tailed unpaired Student's t test (for two groups) or by one-way RM analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Holm-Sidak comparison, or, if a normality distribution Shapiro-Wilk test failed, we used one-way ANOVA on ranks followed by Student-NewmanKeuls comparison.…”

Resveratrol Preconditioning Protects Against Cerebral Ischemic Injury via Nuclear Erythroid 2–Related Factor 2

“…10 μg of nuclear samples were used for the TransAM Nrf2 enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kit (Active Motif) to measure DNA-binding of activated Nrf2 nuclear protein, as determined by absorbance measurements at 450nm. For immunoblotting, cells were lysed in Radioimmunoprecipitation assay (RIPA) buffer and immunoblotted for Nrf2, uncoupler protein 2 (UCP2), GAPDH, β-actin, manganese superoxide dismutase (MnSOD), or Lamin B. Proteins were detected using enhanced chemiluminescence system (Pierce, ThermoScientific) and densitometry was performed using ImageJ (National Institute of Health) 16 .…”