Evaluating factors affecting patient satisfaction using the Kano model

Abstract

Purpose Healthcare providers are increasing their focus on patient satisfaction and patient-oriented services as they play a significant role in managing rising costs, elevating service quality and establishing sustainable quality improvement strategies. In recent years, the Kano model has gained popularity in the healthcare industry and has been employed to improve patient satisfaction. The purpose of this paper is to illustrate how the Kano model can be deployed to identify a wide range of complex patient needs and convey its potential usefulness in the continuous improvement of the healthcare sector. Design/methodology/approach This paper provides a case study of implementing the Kano model to identify diverse patient needs and aims to eliminate the gaps identified in prior research, which include generically applying the Kano model to all service units of the healthcare system and using a predetermined service quality scale. This study emphasizes the importance of scale development and individual attention to each healthcare service unit in determining intricate patient needs. A cross-sectional study was conducted at the Student Health Services (SHS) of Missouri University of Science and Technology where the data were collected using the Kano survey. The respondents included undergraduate and graduate students that have utilized the healthcare services offered. A total of 138 patients were surveyed using a Kano model-based questionnaire that included demographics and treatment as well as service expectations. Findings Of the 21 quality attributes evaluated by the patients, 16 were categorized as one-dimensional, 3 as indifferent, and 2 as attractive attributes using the Kano model. None of the quality attributes showed a dominant must-be feature. The students considered the availability of appropriately qualified medical staff within 10 minutes of the check-in process and provision of after-hours care as attractive attributes that create greater satisfaction. Research limitations/implications The research was conducted at a university SHS center. Therefore, respondents in the survey are in a younger age group, which may affect patient expectations. In addition, expectations of an SHS center may be different than expectations of visiting a primary care physician and other healthcare units. Originality/value This study contributes to a better understanding of the identification of healthcare needs using the Kano model and advocates focusing on shifts in the categories over time and changes in the demographic environment.

Co-Design in the Development of a Mobile Health App for the Management of Knee Osteoarthritis by Patients and Physicians: Qualitative Study

“…The Kano survey is based on the theory of attractive quality, often used to assess and relate customer satisfaction with specific quality attributes [ 37 ]. In health care, it is used for function-satisfaction interface [ 38 ] assessments, including patient perceptions of service quality and quality expectations, quality elements, patient-provider relationships, satisfaction, and assessing how expectations vary with increased awareness to inform appropriate and aligned service requirement design [ 38 ].…”

Quality Evaluation of Health Services Using the Kano Model in Two Hospitals in Peru

“…Traditionally, user satisfaction is measured in a one-dimensional way [ 51 ], that is, the level of satisfaction of a user is considered proportional only to the performance of the service offered [ 52 ]. However, this linear relationship between the variables of satisfaction and quality of service is imprecise [ 25 ]. To overcome this one-dimensional limitation, the Kano model provides a dualistic approach.…”

“…A need to adapt the Kano model to the healthcare field arises from the lack of a systematic method to improve the quality of health services [ 22 ]. Although the Kano model was originally used to raise the quality of a product developed in the manufacturing field [ 23 ], it has also been applied in different industries and services [ 24 ], including health services [ 22 , 25 , 26 , 27 ] and other sectors, such as tourism [ 28 ], education [ 29 ], and banking [ 30 ].…”

RPA Vendor Evaluation and Selection using AHP and Kano Model

“…Using Kano Model could give insights to "Hong Kong Express to identify their service areas that needed to be improved and paid attention to increase customers' satisfaction in future" (Wong & Ho, 2019) "Kano model can be deployed to identify a wide range of complex patient needs and convey its potential usefulness in the continuous improvement of the healthcare sector." (Materla et al, 2019). It has also proven effective to identify "how different after-sales services quality elements affect customer satisfaction"(Shokouhyar et al, 2020).…”