Ethnographic and participatory approaches to research on farmers’ responses to climate predictions

Abstract

This article synthesizes the state of the art in the application of ethnographic and participatory methods in climate application research. The review focuses on 2 aspects: (1) the cognitive and cultural landscape in which farmers' understanding of climate and climate information is grounded and (2) the decision-making processes and environment which shape farmers' adaptive strategies. The first part analyzes methods to elicit how farmers perceive and predict climate events and how these perspectives relate to scientific forecasts. It addresses the long-standing question of whether and how farmers understand the probabilistic nature of climate forecasts and how they assess the credibility and accuracy of such information. The second part examines approaches to characterizing the vulnerability of decision makers and to elucidating the configuration of options and obstacles that farmers face in using climate forecasts to mitigate risk. The complexities of farmers' decisions and the difficulties of identifying the exact role that climate predictions play (and, therefore, of directly attributing impacts to them) are taken into account. Finally, the review highlights efforts to transcend the localized focus of farmer-centered approaches in order to capture interactions across sectors and scales. The review concludes by proposing that climate application research move from a 'technology-adoption' paradigm to a broader perspective on vulnerability and adaptation. This shift will entail a cross-scale, multi-sited research design and an interdisciplinary mix of interactive and structured tools and techniques. It will also require that the analytical focus be expanded to encompass local communities and their multiple action spaces as well as the higher spheres of decision-making, where policy and science are shaped. KEY WORDS: Farmer participatory research · Ethnographic methods · Climate forecasts · Risk communication · Livelihood adaptation · VulnerabilityResale or republication not permitted without written consent of the publisher

Gendered vulnerabilities to climate change: insights from the semi-arid regions of Africa and Asia

“…Roncoli, 2006) to this rather gloomy picture in terms of the effects of vulnerability on the status of married women, as Whitehead and Kabeer (2001) point out, despite women's central role in production processes in Africa, intra-household gender relations reflect a host of inequalities, taken for granted by both communities and researchers. In the context of stress and scarcity, when policy responses fail to take account of changing gender roles and domestic arrangements, it is not surprising to find women and men renegotiating marriage and kinship relations, to support processes of adaptation.…”

Farmers’ Perception and Willingness to Pay for Climate Information in Burkina Faso

“…The use of seasonal climate forecasts based on indigenous knowledge is a traditional strategy of West African farmers to reduce climate risks on their crop yields (Roncoli, 2006;Nyong, Adesina, & Osman, 2007). This traditional seasonal climate forecast, operating as an endogenous system of climate information, guides farmers to make choices on plots to cultivate, types of crop varieties and planting date.…”

Indigenous Past Climate Knowledge as Cultural Built-in Object and Its Accuracy

“…The complementarities of the two kinds of knowledge were differently explored in studies concerned with climate variability. Indeed, indigenous knowledge on climate variability was valorized rather for its prospective value in seasonal rainfall forecasting (Orlove et al 2000, Roncoli et al 2002, Vogel and O'Brien 2003, Roncoli 2006) than for its accuracy in identifying past extreme climatic events as indigenous people experienced them. However, assessing the accuracy of the indigenous climate knowledge remains a largely untapped area (Huntington et al 2004, Gearheard et al 2010.…”