Efficacy of different front-of-package labeling systems in changing purchase intention and product healthfulness perception for food products in Argentina

Abstract

Objectives. To identify the front-of-package scheme—Multiple Traffic Light (MTL), Nutri-Score (NS), and black octagon Warning System (WS)—most effective in reducing purchase intention and perceived product healthfulness of drinking yogurts, cookies and cheese spreads, and to assess the joint influence of nutrient claims on the effects. Methods. Randomized-controlled experiment. A within-subjects factorial design was used to evaluate the influence of three independent factors on perceived product healthfulness and purchase intention. A total of 704 adults in Argentina were shown three mock-up products and asked to indicate which product they would buy choosing between pairs of products from different categories and to rate product healthfulness on a 7-point Likert scale. Results. The WS was the most effective in reducing purchase intention in drinking yogurts (OR:0.16, 95%CI: 0.09;0.28), cookies (OR:0.10, 95%CI: 0.05;0.18) and cheese spreads (OR:0.10, 95%CI: 0.05;0.18), and the perception of healthfulness (WS Mean score 3,63 vs No label 4,24, p<0.001), regardless of the participants’ gender, age, and level of education. NS was inefficacious in reducing product healthfulness perception, while MTL had significantly increased how healthful the product was perceived (p<0.001). Nutrient claims increased purchase intention and perception of healthfulness, thus reducing the effectiveness of front-of-package labels (p<0.001). Conclusions. In line with growing evidence, our findings support that WS perform better than NS and MTL in reducing purchase intention and healthfulness perception of products with excessive amounts of critical nutrients associated with the greatest burden of diseases. Front-of-package WS are expected to facilitate the population in Argentina to make healthier decisions.

How Promising Are “Ultraprocessed” Front-of-Package Labels? A Formative Study with US Adults

“…If scanned, this code led participants to a website that explained what a QR code is. Labels were octagon-shaped, since this design has been shown to perform the most consistently at improving consumers' understanding of nutrient content and eliciting behavior change across a range of contexts [56][57][58][59][60]. The nutrient label used a black background with white text, mimicking the design used in countries like Chile and Mexico [44], while the "ultraprocessed" label used a white background with black text to distinguish processing level as a separate product dimension [49].…”

Front-End Nutrition Labeling and Eco-Labeling Models for Public Health Promotion

“…Formatul interpretativ Nutri-Score pare a fi un instrument mai eficient decât NutrInform pentru orientarea consumatorilor italieni către alegeri alimentare mai favorabile din punct de vedere nutrițional [23]. Conform altor studii, etichetele de avertizare funcționează mai bine decât modelele cromatice, cum ar fi etichetele tip-semafor și Nutri-Score (Figuri 2-5) pentru a descuraja achiziționarea de produse nesănătoase și pentru a reduce cantitatea de calorii și grăsimi saturate achiziționate și în lipsa etichetelor, etichetele de avertizare au redus conținutul de calorii și zahăr al produselor achiziționate, în timp ce alte sisteme nu au avut niciun efect asupra achizițiilor [24]. Surse: [6,11,24].…”

A Little Bird Told Me… Nutri-Score Panoramas from a Flight over Europe, Connecting Science and Society

“…48,80,81,[87][88][89][90][91][92][93][94][95][96][97][98][99][100][101][102][103][104][105] advertising and prevention of childhood obesity in Spain: Analysis of the nutritional value of the products and discursive strategies used in the ads most viewed by children from 2016 to 2018[70] Soft drinks and sugar-sweetened beverages advertising in Spain: Correlation between nutritional values and advertising discursive strategies[65] Breakfast food advertising and prevention of obesity: Analysis of the nutritional value of the products and discursive strategies used in the breakfast ads from 2015…”