ObjectivesTo examine the effect of automatic communication notifications on performance and strain. Because of the benefits of communication, we expected this effect to be moderated by fear of missing out (FoMO) and social norms of responsiveness, expressed in the experience of telepressure.MethodsA field experiment (N = 247) was conducted in which participants in the experimental group disabled their notification during 1 day (N = 124).ResultsThe findings revealed that a reduction of notification‐caused interruptions is beneficial for performance and reducing strain. The moderating of FoMO and telepressure was significant for performance.ConclusionsBased on these findings, reducing the number of notifications is recommended, especially for employee's low in FoMO and medium to high telepressure. Future work needs to analyze the role of anxiety impeding cognitive performance when notifications are disabled.