Ecologic association between influenza and COVID-19 mortality rates in European countries

Abstract

Ecologic studies investigating COVID-19 mortality determinants, used to make predictions and design public health control measures, generally focused on population-based variable counterparts of individual-based risk factors. Influenza is not causally associated with COVID-19, but shares population-based determinants, such as similar incidence/mortality trends, transmission patterns, efficacy of non-pharmaceutical interventions, comorbidities and underdiagnosis. We investigated the ecologic association between influenza mortality rates and COVID-19 mortality rates in the European context. We considered the 3-year average influenza (2014–2016) and COVID-19 (31 May 2020) crude mortality rates in 34 countries using EUROSTAT and ECDC databases and performed correlation and regression analyses. The two variables – log transformed, showed significant Spearman's correlation ρ = 0.439 (P = 0.01), and regression coefficients, b = 0.743 (95% confidence interval, 0.272–1.214; R2 = 0.244; P = 0.003), b = 0.472 (95% confidence interval, 0.067–0.878; R2 = 0.549; P = 0.02), unadjusted and adjusted for confounders (population size and cardiovascular disease mortality), respectively. Common significant determinants of both COVID-19 and influenza mortality rates were life expectancy, influenza vaccination in the elderly (direct associations), number of hospital beds per population unit and crude cardiovascular disease mortality rate (inverse associations). This analysis suggests that influenza mortality rates were independently associated with COVID-19 mortality rates in Europe, with implications for public health preparedness, and implies preliminary undetected SARS-CoV-2 spread in Europe.

Impact that the COVID‐19 pandemic on routine childhood vaccinations and challenges ahead: A narrative review

“…Petti et al 39 ecological study, including data from thirty‐four European countries, found an inverse correlation between the extent of influenza vaccination coverage and the risk of death from COVID‐19. Other authors have suggested a reduced risk of SARS‐CoV‐2 infection in subjects vaccinated with the influenza vaccine.…”

Undetected and Relatively Sustained Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 Circulation Worldwide During 2019

“…was correlated with the distribution of influenza mortality rates in the years 2016-2019, suggesting that in Spring 2020, SARS-CoV-2 circulation in Europe was already as sustained as the endemic influenza virus in previous years [13].…”

COVID-19 Is Not the Flu: Four Graphs From Four Countries

“…Regarding our second implication, even though many of the parallels drawn between COVID-19 and influenza have already been discredited (20)(21)(22)(23)(24)(25)(26), it is often difficult to communicate this to the wider population. Our epidemiological mapping provides visually intuitive support to this difference which can help combat the misinformation that the impact of COVID-19 is no different to influenza.…”