Does the Level of Motivation of Physical Education Teachers Matter in Terms of Job Satisfaction and Emotional Exhaustion? A Person-Centered Examination Based on Self-Determination Theory

Abstract

Grounded in self-determination theory (SDT), prior research has demonstrated that physical education (PE) teachers may have different reasons to engage in teaching. Although some person-centered studies have identified varied motivational profiles in PE teachers, none of these studies have included the three forms of motivation (i.e., autonomous motivation, controlled motivation, and amotivation). This study aims to identify teachers’ motivational profiles, using the three forms of motivation. Moreover, differences between the obtained profiles in terms of job satisfaction and emotional exhaustion were examined. A sample of 107 primary school PE teachers participated. Four distinct motivational profiles were identified: “relatively amotivated”, “somewhat motivated”, “autonomous-controlled motivated”, and “relatively autonomously motivated”. Results showed that the predominantly autonomously motivated PE teachers reported the most adaptive pattern of outcomes. Although PE teachers from the “relatively autonomously motivated” group did not differ in terms of job satisfaction when compared to those in the “autonomous-controlled motivated” group, the former displayed lower values of emotional exhaustion. These findings support SDT in that more motivation is not necessarily better if this additional motivation comes from controlled reasons. These results could raise awareness among school stakeholders about the importance of increasing PE teachers’ autonomous motivation.

The Role of Sense of Power in Alleviating Emotional Exhaustion in Frontline Managers: A Dual Mediation Model

“…For example, individuals with emotional exhaustion are prone to chronic diseases [37], reduced job satisfaction, lower job performance [10], diminished organizational loyalty [38], and higher absenteeism [11]. Prior work has primarily focused on the emotional exhaustion of enterprise employees, teachers, and medical staff (e.g., [9,39,40]). Few studies have involved the problem of emotional exhaustion of frontline managers.…”

Examining Gender Differences, Personality Traits, Academic Performance, and Motivation in Ukrainian and Polish Students of Physical Education: A Cross-Cultural Study

“…Indeed, recent research showed that the perceived transformational relationship between PE teachers’ behavior and students’ PA was stronger when students were harmoniously passionate and self-determined [ 8 ]. Furthermore, Abós et al [ 18 ] showed that autonomously motivated PE teachers, who enjoy and value their teaching, reported lower levels of emotional exhaustion. Thus, autonomous motivation may increase job satisfaction and mental well-being and may also prevent burnout among PE teachers.…”

Teacher Induction Pathway of Physical and Health Education: A Case Study

“…Thus, satisfaction of the needs for autonomy, competence and relatedness impacts motivation at work, engagement and satisfaction (Gagné & Deci, 2005). According to Abós et al (2019), experienced PHE teachers are more likely to become actively engaged in their teaching role and to experience greater satisfaction when their motivation is self-determined. There is little research on teachers' motivation during the TI stage, although motivation is frequently mentioned as a contributing factor in their perseverance (Abós et al, 2019;Desmeules, Hamel, & Frenette, 2017).…”

“…It appears that type of employment is the main reason for fluctuating motivation levels during the first five years of professional integration. A source of motivation, the contract is considered to offer the stability required to develop relationships with students and evaluate their progress in the opinion of Abós et al (2019). Over the years, contact with the same students and collaboration with colleagues have nuanced the comments of Anna and Victor.…”