We have recently encountered patients incorrectly diagnosed with adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (APRT) deficiency due to misidentification of a kidney stone component as 2,8-dihydroxyadenine (DHA). The objective of this study was to examine the accuracy of stone analysis for identification of DHA.
Medical records of patients referred to the Rare Kidney Stone Consortium APRT DeficiencyResearch Program in 2010-2018 with a presumptive diagnosis of APRT deficiency based on kidney stone analysis were reviewed. The diagnosis was verified by measurement of APRT enzyme activity or genetic testing. Available infrared spectra of patients' stone materials were compared with an attenuated total reflection-Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) reference spectrum of pure crystalline DHA generated in our laboratory. In addition, an ATR-FTIR spectrum of a stone sample obtained from one of the patients was recorded. . Of 17 patients referred following identification of DHA kidney stones a diagnosis of APRT deficiency based on kidney stone analysis, 14 had sufficient data available to be included in the study. In all cases, the stone analysis had been performed by ATR-FTIR spectroscopy. In 7 cases, the diagnosis of APRT deficiency was confirmed by demonstrating abolished APRT activity and/or pathogenic biallelic APRT mutations. The ATR-FTIR analysis of a kidney stone from one of these patients matched the reference DHA spectrum. In the 7 remaining cases, the diagnosis of APRT deficiency was rejected. Stone samples these patients had been reported to contain DHA, ranging from 12-100% (median of 60%) in 6 cases and trace amounts in 1 sample. Comparison of available infrared spectra of stone specimens from three of these cases with the ATR-FTIR reference DHA spectrum of a genuine DHA stone specimen showed no detectable DHA in any of the stone samples.