Differential impact of student behaviours on group interaction and collaborative learning: medical students’ and tutors’ perspectives

Abstract

BackgroundCollaboration is of increasing importance in medical education and medical practice. Students’ and tutors’ perceptions about small group learning are valuable to inform the development of strategies to promote group dynamics and collaborative learning. This study investigated medical students’ and tutors’ views on competencies and behaviours which promote effective learning and interaction in small group settings.MethodsThis study was conducted at UNSW Australia. Five focus group discussions were conducted with first and second year medical students and eight small group tutors were interviewed. Data were transcribed verbatim and thematic analysis was conducted.ResultsStudents and tutors identified a range of behaviours that influenced collaborative learning. The main themes that emerged included: respectfulness; dominance, strong opinions and openness; constructiveness of feedback; active listening and contribution; goal orientation; acceptance of roles and responsibilities; engagement and enthusiasm; preparedness; self- awareness and positive personal attributes. An important finding was that some of these student behaviours were found to have a differential impact on group interaction compared with collaborative learning. This information could be used to promote higher quality learning in small groups.ConclusionThis study has identified medical students’ and tutors’ perceptions regarding interactional behaviours in small groups, as well as behaviours which lead to more effective learning in those settings. This information could be used to promote learning in small groups.

Voluntary attendance of small-group brainstorming tutoring courses intensify new clerk’s “excellence in clinical care”: a pilot study

“…During our small-group brainstorming courses, the participants were given problems to stimulate discussion on the relevant topics; this allow them to pool their knowledge as they developed a consensus and ultimately this helped them to teach each other. The process, during which they struggled with a complex clinical scenario in a small-group setting, helped reinforce content objectives and brought learners to a higher level of understanding and cohesiveness [14–16]. In our study, the above mention advantages of small-group tutoring courses were translated into higher post-block self-assessment confidence, greater satisfaction and better performance in “clinical excellence” OSCE.…”

The collaborative learning development exercise (CLeD-EX): an educational instrument to promote key collaborative learning behaviours in medical students

“…This involved adopting a systematic approach towards designing a creative and innovative instrument which would help solve real-world challenges in developing collaborative learning skills in junior medical students. The details of this work have been reported by the authors in prior publications [34,35]. The systematic approach involved a qualitative exploration of key collaborative learning behaviours which are influential in promoting effective collaborative learning [34].…”

“…The details of this work have been reported by the authors in prior publications [34,35]. The systematic approach involved a qualitative exploration of key collaborative learning behaviours which are influential in promoting effective collaborative learning [34]. In the next step, a modified Delphi study was conducted and the top six, key student behaviour which were influential in promoting effective collaborative learning were identified [35].…”

Teaching strategies for the clinical environment

“…Understanding learners' backgrounds allows you to harness the strengths and experiences that each learner brings to the clinical setting. Many have important prior experience and knowledge, have worked in various settings and can offer unique perspectives or expertise on a topic . Educators can learn more about their learners' backgrounds (including the amount of time spent on this rotation previously and prior rotations they have completed) during the sessions described under recommendation 4.…”

“…Many have important prior experience and knowledge, have worked in various settings and can offer unique perspectives or expertise on a topic. 11,12 Educators can learn more about their learners' backgrounds (including the amount of time spent on this rotation previously and prior rotations they have completed) during the sessions described under recommendation 4. Harnessing learners' strengths is an effective way to engage individuals, increase satisfaction and foster a collaborative environment.…”