Developing Clinical Strength-of-Evidence Approach to Define HIV-Associated Malignancies for Cancer Registration in Kenya

Abstract

BackgroundSub-Saharan Africa cancer registries are beset by an increasing cancer burden further exacerbated by the AIDS epidemic where there are limited capabilities for cancer-AIDS match co-registration. We undertook a pilot study based on a “strength-of-evidence” approach using clinical data that is abstracted at the time of cancer registration for purposes of linking cancer diagnosis to AIDS diagnosis.Methods/FindingsThe standard Nairobi Cancer Registry form was modified for registrars to abstract the following clinical data from medical records regarding HIV infection/AIDS in a hierarchal approach at time of cancer registration from highest-to-lowest strength-of-evidence: 1) documentation of positive HIV serology; 2) antiretroviral drug prescription; 3) CD4+ lymphocyte count; and 4) WHO HIV clinical stage or immune suppression syndrome (ISS), which is Kenyan terminology for AIDS. Between August 1 and October 31, 2011 a total of 1,200 cancer cases were registered. Of these, 171 cases (14.3%) met clinical strength-of-evidence criteria for association with HIV infection/AIDS; 69% (118 cases were tumor types with known HIV association – Kaposi’s sarcoma, cervical cancer, non-Hodgkin’s and Hodgkin’s lymphoma, and conjunctiva carcinoma) and 31% (53) were consistent with non-AIDS defining cancers. Verifiable positive HIV serology was identified in 47 (27%) cases for an absolute seroprevalence rate of 4% among the cancer registered cases with an upper boundary of 14% among those meeting at least one of strength-of-evidence criteria.Conclusions/SignificanceThis pilot demonstration of a hierarchal, clinical strength-of-evidence approach for cancer-AIDS registration in Kenya establishes feasibility, is readily adaptable, pragmatic, and does not require additional resources for critically under staffed cancer registries. Cancer is an emerging public health challenge, and African nations need to develop well designed population-based studies in order to better define the impact and spectrum of malignant disease in the backdrop of HIV infection.

Economic analysis of the Nairobi Cancer Registry: Implications for expanding and enhancing cancer registration in Kenya

“…Findings from the pilot study [6] showed that the registry required minimal resources (if any) to collect these additional data hence the registry continued to document HIV as one of its variables.…”

Optimal management of endemic Burkitt lymphoma: a holistic approach mindful of limited resources

“…38 In addition, concerted efforts to develop and strengthen national cancer registries in sub-Saharan countries have arisen, particularly pertaining to HIV and acquired immunodeficiency syndrome-related cancers. 39 Following a proper diagnosis of BL, every child should also undergo staging of the tumor in order to accurately assess the extent of disease. In resource-rich settings, disease extent informs treatment decisions such that more advanced tumors are treated more aggressively and less advanced tumors require less intensive treatment.…”