Desired emotions across cultures: A value-based account.

Abstract

Values reflect how people want to experience the world; emotions reflect how people actually experience the world. Therefore, we propose that across cultures people desire emotions that are consistent with their values. Whereas prior research focused on the desirability of specific affective states or 1 or 2 target emotions, we offer a broader account of desired emotions. After reporting initial evidence for the potential causal effects of values on desired emotions in a preliminary study (N = 200), we tested the predictions of our proposed model in 8 samples (N = 2,328) from distinct world cultural regions. Across cultural samples, we found that people who endorsed values of self-transcendence (e.g., benevolence) wanted to feel more empathy and compassion, people who endorsed values of self-enhancement (e.g., power) wanted to feel more anger and pride, people who endorsed values of openness to change (e.g., self-direction) wanted to feel more interest and excitement, and people who endorsed values of conservation (e.g., tradition) wanted to feel more calmness and less fear. These patterns were independent of differences in emotional experience. We discuss the implications of our value-based account of desired emotions for understanding emotion regulation, culture, and other individual differences. (PsycINFO Database Record

Sad as a Matter of Evidence: The Desire for Self-Verification Motivates the Pursuit of Sadness in Clinical Depression

“…To assess participants' general preference for sadness (vs. happiness), we followed previous studies that assessed motivation to experience emotions (Kim et al, 2015;Tamir et al, 2016). Participants rated the degree to which they generally wanted to experience happiness and sadness in daily life (1 = not at all, 7 = extremely; e.g., "Please indicate the extent to which you generally want to feel happiness in your daily life").…”

What Can We Learn About Aggression From What Adolescents Consider Important in Life? The Contribution of Values Theory to Aggression Research

“…Although the mediating role of emotions in the relations between values and aggression has never been tested, theory suggests that values might activate specific emotions, and, indeed, evidence shows that values relate to specific emotions. For example, in a cross‐cultural study of adults, self‐enhancement values were related to a desire to feel anger (Tamir et al, ), and in a study of Finnish adolescents, guilt and empathy were correlated negatively with power values and associated positively with universalism and benevolence values (Silfver, Helkama, Lönnqvist, & Verkasalo, ).…”

Ideal affect in daily life: implications for affective experience, health, and social behavior

“…Other recent research has examined the valuation of more complex emotional states; for instance, Tamir and colleagues [40] have demonstrated that across a variety of different national contexts, people want to feel the specific emotional states that are consistent with their values. For instance, the more people value self-transcendence (e.g., benevolence), the more they want to feel self-transcending emotions such as empathy and compassion.…”