The effects of protonation on the geometries and stabilization
energies of prototypical •CH2X radicals
(X
= NH2, OH, OCH3, PH2, SH, F, Cl,
Br, CN, CHO, and NO2) have been studied with the use of ab
initio molecular
orbital calculations at the G2 level. The proton affinities at X
of the •CH2X radicals and the analogous
substituted
methanes, CH3X, are compared and the corresponding heats of
formation calculated. For π-donor substituents (X
= NH2, OH, OCH3, PH2, SH, F, Cl
and Br), protonation at X leads to considerable +C :XH
character for both
CH3XH+ and
•CH2XH+, resulting in
substantially lower heterolytic bond dissociation enthalpies and longer
C−X
bonds. Protonation also strengthens the C−H bonds in
CH3XH+ and, in combination with the
reduced interaction
of the lone pair on X with the singly-occupied orbital at the radical
center in the radicals, results in negative radical
stabilization energies for
•CH2XH+. For the
π-acceptor substituents (CN, CHO, and NO2), protonation
enhances
hyperconjugative electron donation from the methyl group to the π*
orbital of X, thereby resulting in C−X bonds
in CH3XH+ and
•CH2XH+ that are
shorter than those in the unprotonated species. This also leads to
weaker C−H
bonds and, together with enhanced delocalization of the unpaired
electron in the radical, leads to positive radical
stabilization energies for
•CH2XH+. The
proton affinities of the radicals with π-donor substituents are
30−70 kJ
mol-1 lower than those of their closed-shell
counterparts. This may be attributed to the decreased availability
of the
lone-pair orbital(s) on X, resulting from interaction with the
singly-occupied orbital at the radical center.
The
•CH2CHO and
•CH2NO2 radicals have
proton affinities that are similar to those of their closed-shell
counterparts
because protonation takes place in a plane almost orthogonal to the
singly-occupied orbital on C, and so there is less
effect in going from CH3X to
•CH2X.