“…For example, for PDX fishbones, when an edge neutral-particle analyzer was tuned to measure high-energy ions in resonance with the mode, the signal consisted almost entirely of coherent oscillatons [21] but, at lower energies, the incoherent portion of the signal was largest [25], with a time evolution resembling the f-FIDA signal reported here. More recent examples of a mixture of coherent and incoherent losses are reported in [26,27]. In the present case, the bump in signal is about 15% of the beam emission, consistent with a rough estimate based on equation (5).…”