Comprehensive Sustainability Evaluation of High-Speed Railway (HSR) Construction Projects Based on Unascertained Measure and Analytic Hierarchy Process

Abstract

This paper aims to evaluate the sustainability of high-speed railway (HSR) construction projects in a comprehensive manner. To this end, the author established an index system, involving 4 primary indices, 9 secondary indices, and 32 tertiary indices. The analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and the unascertained measure were introduced to calculate the weights of these indices. Then, the index system was applied to evaluate the sustainability of the China's Harbin-Dalian Passenger Dedicated Line (PDL). The results show that the Harbin-Dalian PDL project achieved good results in terms of process, economic benefit, impact, and sustainability, and will bring long-term benefits in the fields of tourism, economy, and transport capacity, as well as many other fields. In spite of its good overall sustainability, the project needs to further increase its economic benefits and reduce its negative environmental impact. For this purpose, it is necessary to adopt the management mode of "separation between network and transportation" and apply noise prevention measures like noise barriers, tunnels, and overhead viaducts. This research lays a solid basis for the sustainability evaluation of HSR construction projects, and simplifies the modelling process for designers of HSR.

Tourism Development, Environment and Policies: Differences between Domestic and International Tourists

“…After studying the economic impact of the high-speed railway construction of China, Chang et al (2018) inferred that railway construction has achieved positive results in terms of economic benefits, social impact, and development sustainability. Railways will bring long-term benefits in the fields of tourism, economy, and transportation [41]. However, Aratuo and Etienne (2019) found a relationship between US economic growth and six tourism-related sub-sectors(i.e., accommodation, air transportation, shopping, food and beverage, other transportation, entertainment, and entertainment).In addition to the accommodation and food and beverage industries, no long-term relationship was found between other tourism sub-sectors and economic growth [7].…”

On the Environmental and Social Sustainability of Technological Innovations in Urban Bus Transport: The EU Case

“…The CR values were 0.04 and 0.03 for the environmental and the social sustainability dimensions, respectively. It is important to point out that unless CR = 0, the expert judgements are not considered to be completely consistent [73]. The CR values reached in our research highlight that the expert judgements did not present a total level of agreement although they were below the limit value and therefore pairwise comparison did not have to be repeated,…”

Electric Bus Selection with Multicriteria Decision Analysis for Green Transportation

“…The basics of AHP methodology involve structuring complex decisions as a hierarchy of goals, criteria, and alternatives, conducting a pairwise comparison of all the elements in each level of the decision hierarchy with respect to each criterion in the previous level of the hierarchy, and vertically synthesizing judgments on different levels of the hierarchy [76] AHP has been applied as a decision-making tool in many contexts due to its simplicity [77]. For instance, it was used in the evaluation and selection of medical tourism sites [78], strategic maintenance technique selection [79], heart disease diagnoses [80], critical criteria influencing the choice of arctic shipping [81], identification of potential aquaculture sites in solar saltscapes [82], ecological vulnerability assessment [83], risk assessment [84], evaluation of high-speed railway (HSR) construction projects [85], selection of suitable sites for wind power in Pakistan [86], and selection of rail system projects [87].…”