Compliance with momentary pain measurement using electronic diaries: A systematic review

Abstract

Electronic diaries are increasingly used to assess daily pain in many different forms and populations. This systematic review aims to survey the characteristics of studies using electronic pain diaries and to examine how these characteristics affect compliance. A literature search of 11 electronic databases was conducted. Studies were evaluated on the basis of predetermined inclusion criteria by two independent reviewers. Study characteristics were grouped into four categories: general, population, electronic diary, and sampling procedure (i.e., response, attrition, and compliance rates) including strategies to enhance compliance. The 62 included publications reported from 43 different datasets. Papers were usually written in English and published as from 2000. Samples mostly consisted of female chronic pain patients aged 19-65 years from western countries. Most diaries held less than 20 items and were completed up to 6 times daily at fixed or prompted times for 1 month at most. Less than 25% of the studies reported both response and attrition rates; however, a majority reported compliance. Compliance was generally high, and positively associated with shorter diaries, age, having a user's manual, financial compensation and using an alarm. It is important that the various study characteristics are catalogued carefully, especially response and attrition rates, because they can affect compliance. Measures of momentary pain are often developed for the purpose of a certain study; standardisation and validation of these measures is recommended. Finally, authors should mention whether they report on data that has also been used in previous studies.

Motive8! Feasibility of a Text Messaging Intervention to Promote Physical Activity in Knee Osteoarthritis

“…for them to text details of the type, frequency and duration of their physical activity at the time of engagement). Electronic diaries may be considered in future studies since they have demonstrated higher rates of compliance (83-94%) [38,40,41].…”

Older adults and mobile technology: Factors that enhance and inhibit utilization in the context of behavioral health

“…A systematic review of studies on pain that utilized electronic DDA implemented via smartphones, personal digital devices, and tablets reported: (a) high compliance rates overall among subjects aged 18 to 83 [55] and (b) rates of compliance significantly increased as the subject's age increased. In a recent study that implemented smartphone-based DDA with 48 problem drinkers aged 50 to 73 demonstrated that 100% had their own smartphones, and compliance rates with the DDA were higher among older adults than the younger cohort (78% vs. 72% over the course of 49 days) [56].…”

Facet joint injections for people with persistent non-specific low back pain (Facet Injection Study): a feasibility study for a randomised controlled trial

“…To test the feasibility of using an electronic diary, a review of studies using electronic diary-related pain or pain-related disability measurement was conducted, as well as the identification or development of an application or text system with candidate diary prompts and FEASIBILITY RANDOMISED CONTROLLED TRIAL NIHR Journals Library www.journalslibrary.nihr.ac.uk choice of prompts and frequency. 117 Research participants find electronic symptom diaries acceptable and can generate valid symptom data. 118 During the exploratory phase, initial feasibility testing, we refined the diary recording for the needs of the trial.…”