Circularity in Practice: Review of Main Current Approaches and Strategic Propositions for an Efficient Circular Economy of Materials

Abstract

This paper aims to summarize, propose, and discuss existing or emerging strategies to shift towards a circular economy of materials. To clarify the landscape of existing circular practices, a new spectrum is proposed, from product-based strategies, where entire products go through several life cycles without being reprocessed, to material-based approaches, extracting, recycling, and reprocessing materials from the waste flow. As refillable packaging does not lose any functionality or value, when re-used through many life cycles, product-based strategies are globally extremely efficient and must be promoted. It appears however that their implementation is only possible at the scale of individual products such as packaging containers, relying on the cooperation of involved companies and consumers. It appears more and more urgent to focus as well on a more systematic and flexible material-oriented scheme. The example of circular glass recycling is a success in many countries, and technologies become nowadays available to extend such practices to many other materials, such as rigid plastics. An ideal would be to aim at an economy of materials that would imitate the continuous material cycle of the biosphere. Technological and business strategies are presented and discussed, aiming at a relevant impact on circularity.

Circular Economy: Illusion or First Step towards a Sustainable Economy: A Physico-Economic Perspective

“…And these processes of self-organization, which lower entropy at least in their subsystems, are also constantly taking place today (for a more detailed discussion see [11]). For an overview about practical applications, see [27].…”

Chemistry and pathways to net zero for sustainability

“…This Perspective considers the connection between net zero and chemistry – the pivotal roles that chemistry, as the science of transformation of matter, can play in achieving it, and the orientations, knowledge and skills that chemists need in order to ensure that the net zero objective translates into sustainability as the outcome. This will bring to the foreground (1) the importance of recognizing and understanding the intimate connections between chemistry processes and Earth systems, highlighting the value of systems thinking as a core competence needed by chemists; (2) the need for the nuanced translation of circular economy ideas into their specific physical adaptation as material circularity, 35 through chemistry and other disciplines, 36,37 to provide the material/molecular basis of sustainability; (3) the value of adopting the planetary boundaries 38 framework to help ensure that anthropogenic activities are contained within the safe operating spaces of Earth systems; and (4) the opportunity for chemistry to develop and display its role in the stewardship of the Earth's material resources, which are embodied in our elemental heritage.…”

Exploring environmental and social performances of circular start‐ups: An orientation and certification assessment

“…In this context, the CE has mainly born in response to reduce the impacts of human activities on the natural environment (Megevand et al, 2022; Mazur‐Wierzbicka, 2021). However, the increasing recognition of the strict connection between the ecological and social crisis (Giraud et al, 2023) as well as the CE potential of contributing to the pursuit of sustainable development (Knäble et al, 2022; Terra dos Santos et al, 2022) requires that CE model aligns to all the three dimensions of sustainability (Evans, 2023).…”