Characterization of Flow-resistant Tubes Used for Semi-occluded Vocal Tract Voice Training and Therapy

Abstract

Objectives To characterize the pressure-flow relationship of tubes used for semi-occluded vocal tract voice training/therapy, as well as to answer these major questions: (1) What is the relative importance of tube length to tube diameter? (2) What is the range of oral pressures achieved with tubes at phonation flow rates? (3) Does mouth configuration behind the tubes matter? Methods Plastic tubes of various diameters and lengths were mounted in line with an upstream pipe, and the pressure drop across each tube was measured at stepwise increments in flow rate. Basic flow theory and modified flow theory equations were used to describe the pressure-flow relationship of the tubes based on diameter and length. Additionally, the upstream pipe diameter was varied to explore how mouth shape affects tube resistance. Results The modified equation provided an excellent prediction of the pressure-flow relationship across all tube sizes (6% error compared to the experimental data). Variation in upstream pipe diameter yielded up to 10% deviation in pressure for tube sizes typically used in voice training/therapy. Conclusions Using the presented equations, resistance can be characterized for any tube based on diameter, length, and flow rate. With regard to the original questions, we found that: (1) For commonly used tubes, diameter is the critical variable for governing flow resistance; (2) For phonation flow rates, a range of tube dimensions produced pressures between 0 and 7.0 kPa; (3) The mouth pressure behind the lips will vary slightly with different mouth shapes, but this effect can be considered relatively insignificant.

The Therapeutic Effects of Straw Phonation on Vocal Fatigue

“…However, no study to date has investigated its effects on vocal fatigue. Straw phonation enjoys several outstanding features, such as easy accessibility, great efficiency, and controllability, when compared with other SOVTEs . Therefore, our study looked to quantify the therapeutic effects of straw phonation on vocal fatigue and compare them with those of vocal rest.…”

Real-Time Visual Feedback of Airflow in Voice Training: Aerodynamic Properties of Two Flow Ball Devices

“…These authors measured the back pressure -flow (P back -U) relationship for different tube lengths and diameters commonly used in voice training, concluding that a change in tube diameter would affect the flow resistance more than a corresponding relative change in tube length. This has later been confirmed by Smith and Titze (article in press), who based on flow theory and empirical data suggested two models for the pressure-flow relationship 11 . This paper aims at exploring the physical properties of two different flow ball devices, the FB and the FBG, in terms of relationships between P back , air flow (U) and ball height (h B ).…”

“…The predictions of tube lengths based on the two flow models by Smith & Titze (in press) varied considerably 11 . It appears as while the models work well for predicting a P back from tube dimensions, they are numerically ill-conditioned when applied backwards, i.e.…”

Cervical Spine Disability in Correlation with Subjective Voice Handicap in Patients With Voice Disorders: A Retrospective Analysis

“…10 As shown in studies examining the effects of flow-resistant tubes in semioccluded vocal tract voice training programs on voice function, the position of the larynx may play a key role in vocal efficiency. 20 Further, Mathieson proposed based on a literature review, that manual therapy may be an efficient primary treatment approach in patients with functional dysphonia. 21 In voice clinics it often remains unclear which complaint, functional voice, or neck-related symptoms, develops first and if or how they interact.…”