Changing Seascapes, Stochastic Connectivity, and Marine Metapopulation Dynamics

Abstract

The probability of dispersal from one habitat patch to another is a key quantity in our efforts to understand and predict the dynamics of natural populations. Unfortunately, an often overlooked property of this potential connectivity is that it may change with time. In the marine realm, transient landscape features, such as mesoscale eddies and alongshore jets, produce potential connectivity that is highly variable in time. We assess the impact of this temporal variability by comparing simulations of nearshore metapopulation dynamics when potential connectivity is constant through time (i.e., when it is deterministic) and when it varies in time (i.e., when it is stochastic). We use mathematical analysis to reach general conclusions and realistic biophysical modeling to determine the actual magnitude of these changes for a specific system: nearshore marine species in the Southern California Bight. We find that in general the temporal variability of potential connectivity affects two important quantities: metapopulation growth rates when the species is rare and equilibrium abundances. Our biophysical models reveal that stochastic outcomes are almost always lower than their deterministic counterparts, sometimes by up to 40%. This has implications for how we use spatial information, such as connectivity, to manage nearshore (and other) systems.

Beyond connectivity: how empirical methods can quantify population persistence to improve marine protected‐area design

“…In reality, connectivity and LEP all likely vary over time. Stochasticity in connectivity can decrease (Watson et al 2012) or increase (Williams and Hastings 2013) metapopulation growth rates.…”

Trait-based modeling of larval dispersal in the Gulf of Maine

“…Huret et al, 2007;Tian et al, 2009a) to tens of millions (e.g. Watson et al, 2012;Jones et al, 2015). Field research that relies on parentage, tagging, or drifter data may be limited to only a few hundred sample points (Almany et al, 2007;Planes et al, 2009).…”

“…IBM studies may simulate tens of millions of particles and consume vast computational resources (e.g. Watson et al, 2012;Jones et al, 2015), and so we seek an alternative method that reduces the required number of particles.…”

“…Watson et al, 2012;Jones et al, 2015;Treml et al, 2015). Although existing IBMs differ in the details of their implementation and the features available to users, the computational challenges facing IBM developers and the solutions to them are highly similar across oceanographic IBMs.…”

Geographic distance, water circulation and environmental conditions shape the biodiversity of Mediterranean rocky coasts

“…Elucidating the mechanisms that control patterns of diversity is a central objective of community ecology (Hubbell 2001, Leibold et al 2004, and has been the focus of considerable research across terrestrial (Tuomisto et al 2003, De Cáceres et al 2012, freshwater (Maloney & Munguia 2011, Angeler 2013) and marine systems (Watson et al 2012, Moritz et al 2013. A better understanding of these mechanisms is critically important for conservation planning, which has historically focussed on prioritizing protection of areas containing high species richness and threatened or endemic species, but often failed to incorporate underlying variation in regional species assembly driven by ecological connectivity, spatial processes and environmental heterogeneity (McKnight et al 2007).…”