Cardiovascular Risk of High- Versus Moderate-Intensity Aerobic Exercise in Coronary Heart Disease Patients

Abstract

Background-Exercise performed at higher relative intensities has been found to elicit a greater increase in aerobic capacity and greater cardioprotective effects than exercise at moderate intensities. An inverse association has also been detected between the relative intensity of physical activity and the risk of developing coronary heart disease, independent of the total volume of physical activity. Despite that higher levels of physical activity are effective in reducing cardiovascular events, it is also advocated that vigorous exercise could acutely and transiently increase the risk of sudden cardiac death and myocardial infarction in susceptible persons. This issue may affect cardiac rehabilitation. Methods and Results-We examined the risk of cardiovascular events during organized high-intensity interval exercise training and moderate-intensity training among 4846 patients with coronary heart disease in 3 Norwegian cardiac rehabilitation centers. In a total of 175 820 exercise training hours during which all patients performed both types of training, we found 1 fatal cardiac arrest during moderate-intensity exercise (129 456 exercise hours) and 2 nonfatal cardiac arrests during high-intensity interval exercise (46 364 exercise hours). There were no myocardial infarctions in the data material. Because the number of high-intensity training hours was 36% of the number of moderate-intensity hours, the rates of complications to the number of patient-exercise hours were 1 per 129 456 hours of moderate-intensity exercise and 1 per 23 182 hours of high-intensity exercise. Conclusions-The results of the current study indicate that the risk of a cardiovascular event is low after both high-intensity exercise and moderate-intensity exercise in a cardiovascular rehabilitation setting. Considering the significant cardiovascular adaptations associated with high-intensity exercise, such exercise should be considered among patients with coronary heart disease. (Circulation. 2012;126:1436-1440.)Key Words: coronary disease Ⅲ death Ⅲ sudden Ⅲ exercise Ⅲ heart arrest H igh levels of physical activity and aerobic capacity are associated with low risk of cardiovascular disease and mortality. 1-3 Aerobic exercise is therefore strongly recommended both for healthy individuals and for patients with cardiovascular disease to improve cardiovascular health and reduce risk of premature mortality. 4,5 If the total energy expenditure of exercise is held constant, exercise performed at higher relative intensities has been found to elicit a greater increase in aerobic capacity 6 and greater cardioprotective effects than exercise at moderate intensities. 7,8 An inverse association has also been detected between the relative intensity of physical activity and the risk of developing coronary heart disease, independent of the total volume of physical activity. 9,10 Indeed, when exercise is performed at high intensity, as little as a single weekly bout of exercise seems to be sufficient for reducing the risk of cardiovascular death in a large uns...

Effects of Leisure‐Time and Transport‐Related Physical Activities on the Risk of Incident and Recurrent Myocardial Infarction and Interaction With Traffic‐Related Air Pollution: A Cohort Study

“…A Swedish study showed a 31% reduced risk for incident MI associated with high versus low leisure‐time physical activities 34. Earlier studies with data on high‐ and moderate‐intensity exercise among CVD patients found that both intensity levels decreased CVD risk, but also pointed to the knowledge gap regarding the right intensity and amount of physical activity in secondary prevention of CVD 35, 36, 37…”

Physical Activity in the Prevention and Treatment of Coronary Artery Disease

“…The authors, therefore, speculated that the total energy spent on exercise training is more important to increasing peak oxygen uptake than exercise intensity 117. The number of serious adverse events with HIT was low and did not differ from MCT in patients with CAD 116, 118. In patients with heart failure, serious adverse events were numerically higher with HIT than with MCT.…”

Impact of cardiac rehabilitation and exercise training programs in coronary heart disease

“…108 In a review of 4846 CHD patients enrolled in interval and continuous CR regimens in Norway, the difference in event rates were 1 in 129,456 hours of moderate ET and 1 in 23,182 hours of high intensity ET. 109 Of such studies, Japan appears to have some of the lowest rates of adverse events, with only 1 life-threatening adverse event occurring in 383,096 patienthours of ET. 110 The most serious CVD complications of structured ET for CVD patients are acute MI and sudden cardiac death, usually from ventricular fibrillation which can be triggered by exercise-induced myocardial ischemia, especially in patients with left ventricular dysfunction.…”