Can disc diffusion susceptibility tests assess the antimicrobial activity of engineered nanoparticles?

Abstract

The use of disc diffusion susceptibility tests to determine the antibacterial activity of engineered nanoparticles (ENPs) is questionable because their low diffusivity practically prevents them from penetrating through the culture media. In this study, we investigate the ability of such a test, namely the Kirby-Bauer disc diffusion test, to determine the antimicrobial activity of Au and Ag ENPs having diameters from 10 to 40 nm on Escherichia coli cultures. As anticipated, the tests did not show any antibacterial effects of Au nanoparticles (NPs) as a result of their negligible diffusivity through the culture media. Ag NPs on the other hand exhibited a strong antimicrobial activity that was independent of their size. Considering that Ag, in contrast to Au, dissolves upon oxidation and dilution in aqueous solutions, the apparent antibacterial behavior of Ag NPs is attributed to the ions they release. The Kirby-Bauer method, and other similar tests, can therefore be employed to probe the antimicrobial activity of ENPs related to their ability to release ions rather than to their unique size-dependent properties. Graphical abstractᅟ

Activity of Specialized Biomolecules against Gram-Positive and Gram-Negative Bacteria

“…AgNPs display a low-activity ZoI, particularly against Gram-negative bacteria. It has been reported that metal nanoparticles tend to form agglomerates when in colloidal dispersions, which reduces their diffusivity, limiting the contact with the bacteria [37]. Here, the presence of agglomerates is evident (Figure 1), supporting this statement.…”

Synergistic Effect of Chitosan and Selenium Nanoparticles on Biodegradation and Antibacterial Properties of Collagenous Scaffolds Designed for Infected Burn Wounds

“…Also, Gram-negative E. coli was not inhibited at all. However, some NPs report lower diffusivity through the agar media, and their reduced penetration causes the limitation of diffusion technique [ 66 ]. Therefore, for the evaluation of these findings, fluorescence microscopy of bacterial cells obtained from these scaffolds was performed ( Figure 9 ).…”

Eco-friendly silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) fabricated by green synthesis using the crude extract of marine polychaete, Marphysa moribidii: biosynthesis, characterisation, and antibacterial applications

“…The Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion method relies on the diffusion of the test substance from a sterile paper disk to bacterial cultures. Thus, this result might be affected by the diffusion rate of particles as metal nanoparticles have low diffusion rate as compared to standard antibiotics ( Kourmouli et al., 2018 ). As a consequence, metal nanoparticles do not travel far from deposition disks to interact physically with the bacterial cells.…”