Bringing together the Listening Guide and Moral Self-Definition for narrative analysis of older people’s understanding of health-related decision-making

Abstract

Identity and decision-making are interrelated concepts, but the relationship between them is complex particularly when an unwell person’s ability to make decisions is compromised. In this article we discuss how moral self-definition (Nelson, 2001;Walker, 1987) can be used within a Listening Guide (LG) analysis to extend analysis of the temporal relationship between identity and decisions. In this project, the LG was used to analyze interviews exploring older people’s understanding of medical decision-making when the unwell person’s capacity is diminished. The second step of the LG drew attention to the participants’ expression of decision-making voices and health-related identities, but the iterative and temporal relationship between identity and decisions was less well illuminated. Therefore, we applied the theoretical framework of moral self-definition within the third listening. The focus of this article is on how moral self-definition can be integrated as a theoretical framework within the contrapuntal listening to extend the LG analysis.

‘How I'm feeling today, I probably won't be feeling tomorrow’. Using I-Poems to explore young people's changing emotions during the Covid-19 pandemic – A qualitative, longitudinal study

“…my, myself, me, and occasional use of ‘our/us’. This aligns with recommendations from Robins-Browne et al (2019) that individual researchers need to determine which pronouns best enable them to address their research questions.…”

Narrating the self-in-relation: How friends’ responses to intimate partner violence shape young women’s identities.

“…It differs from traditional thematic analysis, which typically fragments a participant’s account into thematic categories and focuses on the content of what is being said. In contrast, the LG explores how content is spoken through changes in voice across a participant’s interview (Robins-Browne et al, 2019; Sorsoli & Tolman, 2008).…”

Engaging older people through visual participatory research: Insights and reflections

“…Beyond participatory research, data collection tools adopted for research involving older people have included data taken from national surveys in China and Europe (see Huang and Wang, 2020;Dingemans and Henkens, 2020); in-depth individual interviews (see Clarke and Korotchenko, 2016;Robins Browne et al, 2019); and mixed methods incorporating focus groups and case studies (see Stirzaker et al, 2019;Patterson et al, 2016).Furthermore, observation based ethnographic study has been undertaken in residential homes (see Reed-Danahay, 2001).…”