Birds are tracking climate warming, but not fast enough

Abstract

Range shifts of many species are now documented as a response to global warming. But whether these observed changes are occurring fast enough remains uncertain and hardly quantifiable. Here, we developed a simple framework to measure change in community composition in response to climate warming. This framework is based on a community temperature index (CTI ) that directly reflects, for a given species assemblage, the balance between low-and high-temperature dwelling species. Using data from the French breeding bird survey, we first found a strong increase in CTI over the last two decades revealing that birds are rapidly tracking climate warming. This increase corresponds to a 91 km northward shift in bird community composition, which is much higher than previous estimates based on changes in species range edges. During the same period, temperature increase corresponds to a 273 km northward shift in temperature. Change in community composition was thus insufficient to keep up with temperature increase: birds are lagging approximately 182 km behind climate warming. Our method is applicable to any taxa with large-scale survey data, using either abundance or occurrence data. This approach can be further used to test whether different delays are found across groups or in different land-use contexts.

Effect of local weather on butterfly flight behaviour, movement, and colonization: significance for dispersal under climate change

“…Yet, only a quarter of these species increased their area of geographical distribution, supposedly because positive responses to climate warming were outweighed by negative effects of habitat fragmentation, especially for less mobile specialists (Travis 2003). Other empirical studies (Anderson et al 2009;Devictor et al 2008;Schwartz et al 2001) confirm for other species groups that a response to climate change may be hampered by habitat fragmentation.…”

Changing conservation strategies in Europe: a framework integrating ecosystem services and dynamics

“…Variable and flexible strategies must be developed to incorporate different dynamics across many scales (Ejrnaes et al 2002;Pärtel et al 2005). Although the EU Habitats Directive recognises priority habitats and species to be conserved (Annex I and II), it does not consider that ecosystems can change through succession, inherent ecosystem dynamics (Evans 2006;Hobbs et al 2006), land use and climate change (Devictor et al 2008). Indeed, site-based conservation strategies, whether local or European such as the Emerald Network (that includes Natura 2000), may be inadequate under a changing climate, whereby a shifting climate space could result in species extinctions within, and migrations from, the designated PAs to areas not managed for conservation.…”

Are Swiss birds tracking climate change?

“…Adaptation can occur predominantly in one particular dimension, but generally involves all of them. When populations cannot adapt in one of these dimensions or cannot adapt fast enough (Devictor et al, 2008;Visser, 2008), a species may be driven to extinction, even though today's projections are probably overestimated (Botkin et al, 2007) due to assumptions and limitations of current forecasting methods (refer to Thuiller, 2004, andThuiller et al, 2008, for the spatial dimension). .…”