Bioethics curriculum in medical schools in Portuguese-speaking countries

Abstract

Background A curriculum is a fundamental tool for educators, and teaching bioethics is fundamental to good medical practice. Studies report a lack of consensus on the teaching of bioethics in undergraduate medicine, and a critical issue is that there remain no minimum curricular parameters. This study performed an analysis between the bioethics curricula of the medical schools of Brazil and Portugal and UNESCO’s Core Curriculum, in addition to proposing key criteria for designing a core bioethics curriculum. Methods This is a cross-sectional, descriptive study that analyzes the bioethics curricula of the medical schools in Brazil and in Portugal. The design of the study includes a qualitative summative content analysis-based approach and a quantitative analysis by means of descriptive statistics. Results Bioethics is taught in both Brazil and Portugal in a diversified way. The results showed that 65.5% of the medical schools analyzed provided at least the 30-h minimum workload recommended by the UNESCO Core Curriculum. Furthermore, bioethics sporadically offered at the end of the medical program in the vast majority of schools studied. Conclusions The most important points to take away from this study are the diversity of the curricular structure of bioethics courses and the lack of formalization of bioethics in the curricula of medical schools in Brazil and Portugal. Given the value of bioethics in clinical practice, we propose that medical schools in Portugal and Brazil update their curricula to encompass minimum criteria, which should be similar to one another and based on common sources, but which should also be tailored to each culture.

Students’ perception of Simulation-based learning in Clinical Skills Lab: A One-year institutional experience at Fazaia Ruth Pfau Medical College

“…A study done by Zhaalts R and colleagues to investigate the association between motivation and learning environment has reported a significant correlation between motivation with learning environment 16 18,19,20 .…”

Bioethics curriculum for undergraduate medical students: an evaluation study utilizing mixed methods approach

“…Studies have highlighted the relevance of understanding culture and religion for a diverse group of students [ 13 , 31 , 32 ]. Moreover, bioethics curriculum tailored culturally has been emphasized for formalization of bioethics in the curricula of medical schools [ 33 ].…”

Ethical and Moral Issues in Undergraduate Medical Education: An Exploratory Study

“…16 Studies show that such clinical teachers who act repulsively with patients are negative role models and interaction with them remains the most frequently cited ethical dilemma amongst students who are keen to learn. 17,18,19 One study carried out in the setting of the emergency department confirms that medical students do encounter day-to-day ethically based issues coded with autonomy, beneficence, and non-maleficence. 20 The presence of these various ethical dilemmas suggests that awareness regarding ethical principles in medical education is lacking or b) there may be a gap between ethical issues being discussed in classes and those being encountered.…”