Beyond Completion Rate: Evaluating the Passing Ability of Footballers

Abstract

Passing the ball is one of the key skills of a football player yet the metrics commonly used to evaluate passing ability are crude and largely limited to various forms of a pass completion rate. These metrics can be misleading for two general reasons: they do not account for the difficulty of the attempted pass nor the various levels of uncertainty involved in empirical observations based on different numbers of passes per player. We address both these deficiencies by building a statistical model in which the success of a pass depends on the skill of the executing player as well as other factors including the origin and destination of the pass, the skill of his teammates and the opponents, and proxies for the defensive pressure put on the executing player as well as random chance. We fit the model by using data from the 2006-2007 season of the English Premier League provided by Opta, estimate each player's passing skill and make predictions for the next season. The model predictions considerably outperform a naive method of simply using the previous season's completion rate as a predictor of the following season's completion rate. In particular, we show how a change in the difficulty of passes attempted in both seasons explains a significant proportion of the shift in the observed performance of some players-a fact that is ignored if the raw completion rate is used to evaluate player skill.

Dolores: a model that predicts football match outcomes from all over the world

“…Finally, past studies have shown that it is possible to increase the predictive accuracy of a model by incorporating other key factors, such as player transfers, availability of key players, participation in international competitions, new coach, level of injuries, attack and defence ratings, and even team motivation/psychology in the form of expert knowledge Pena 2014;Szczepanski and McHale 2015;Constantinou and Fenton 2017). Because of the competition requirements and the multiple leagues captured by the dataset, the model presented in this paper had to be restricted to goal scoring data.…”

The undervalued set piece: Analysis of soccer throw-ins during the English Premier League 2018–2019 season

“…This results in a 'fight ball' being thrown down the line into an unfavourable situation and therefore in a loss of first contact and ball possession retention. Furthermore, when throwing forwards the aim might be for players to head/flick the ball onto a teammate, however, as Szczepa nski and McHale 22 demonstrate headed passes are less accurate and have a negative effect of the following pass, in comparison to those passed from the ground, hence might lead to a loss of possession. The results here, suggest the common coaching principle of throwing the ball forwards and long away from the goal in the defensive half is an ineffective tactic.…”

Machine learning in men’s professional football: Current applications and future directions for improving attacking play

“…Another study focused on creating an individual evaluation tool for player recruitment that evaluated the passing ability of individual players by controlling for the difficulty of their attempts based on the probability of completion. 60 Contextual factors such as the skill of the player and the conditions of the player passing the ball were unable to be considered, and only the distance between the passer and the receiver could be derived directly from the model. Thus, comparing players performing similar types of passes, in similar circumstances, was most useful.…”