Benefit-cost analysis of the policy of mandatory annual rabies vaccination of domestic dogs in rabies-free Japan

Abstract

Japan is one of the few rabies-free countries/territories which implement the policy of mandatory vaccination of domestic dogs. In order to assess the economic efficiency of such policy in reducing the economic burden of a future canine rabies outbreak in Japan, a benefit-cost analysis (BCA) was performed using probabilistic decision tree modelling. Input data derived from simulation results of published mathematical model, field investigation conducted by the authors at prefectural governments, literature review, international or Japanese database and empirical data of rabies outbreaks in other countries/territories. The current study revealed that the annual costs of implementing the current vaccination policy would be US$160,472,075 (90% prediction interval [PI]: $149,268,935–171,669,974). The economic burden of a potential single canine rabies outbreak in Japan were estimated to be US$1,682,707 (90% PI: $1,180,289–2,249,283) under the current vaccination policy, while it would be US$5,019,093 (90% PI: $3,986,882–6,133,687) under hypothetical abolition of vaccination policy, which is 3-fold higher. Under a damage-avoided approach, the annual benefits of implementing the current vaccination policy in expected value were estimated to be US$85.75 (90% PI: $55.73–116.89). The benefit-cost ratio (BCR) was estimated to be 5.35 X 10−7 (90% PI: 3.46 X 10−7–7.37 X 10−7), indicating that the implementation of the current policy is very economically inefficient for the purpose of reducing the economic burden of a potential canine rabies outbreak. In worse-case scenario analysis, the BCR would become above 1 (indicating economic efficiency) if the risk of rabies introduction increased to 0.04 corresponding to a level of risk where rabies would enter Japan in 26 years while the economic burden of a rabies outbreak under the abolition of vaccination policy increased to $7.53 billion. Best-case analysis further revealed that under relatively extreme circumstances the economic efficiency of the current policy could be improved by decreasing the vaccination price charged to dog owners, relaxing the frequency of vaccination to every two to three years and implementing the policy on a smaller scale, e.g. only in targeted prefectures instead of the whole Japan.

The final stages of dog rabies elimination from Japan

“…With the strict quarantine policy, the risk of dog rabies introduction to Japan has been assessed to be very low (Kwan et al, 2017). The benefits for Japan to maintain mandatory dog rabies vaccination are high level of public and veterinary awareness of rabies prevention and a stable supply of animal rabies vaccines, but the cost is high (Kwan et al, 2018;Yamada et al, 2019).…”

The Effectiveness of Rabies Control Program in West Bandung Regency, West Java, Indonesia

“…Based on this study, whereas the data that we used are the estimation such as the dog population and the estimation of the number human infected, this impact should not be underestimated. A study in South Africa using highly dynamic population shown that 70% coverage rabies vaccination is effective to maintain critical threshold of rabies infection [13].…”

The current status of neglected tropical diseases in Japan: A scoping review

“…Even when a rabid dog enters Japan, it is unlikely to cause large outbreaks [247], partly because the probability for a dog to have contact with other dogs is low in Japan [248]. In that situation, the implementation of mandatory vaccination was shown to be economically inefficient [249,250].…”