Behavioral heterogeneity in quorum sensing can stabilize social cooperation in microbial populations

Abstract

BackgroundMicrobial communities are susceptible to the public goods dilemma, whereby individuals can gain an advantage within a group by utilizing, but not sharing the cost of producing, public goods. In bacteria, the development of quorum sensing (QS) can establish a cooperation system in a population by coordinating the production of costly and sharable extracellular products (public goods). Cooperators with intact QS system and robust ability in producing public goods are vulnerable to being undermined by QS-deficient defectors that escape from QS but benefit from the cooperation of others. Although microorganisms have evolved several mechanisms to resist cheating invasion in the public goods game, it is not clear why cooperators frequently coexist with defectors and how they form a relatively stable equilibrium during evolution.ResultsWe show that in Pseudomonas aeruginosa, QS-directed social cooperation can select a conditional defection strategy prior to the emergence of QS-mutant defectors, depending on resource availability. Conditional defectors represent a QS-inactive state of wild type (cooperator) individual and can invade QS-activated cooperators by adopting a cheating strategy, and then revert to cooperating when there are abundant nutrient supplies irrespective of the exploitation of QS-mutant defector. Our mathematical modeling further demonstrates that the incorporation of conditional defection strategy into the framework of iterated public goods game with sound punishment mechanism can lead to the coexistence of cooperator, conditional defector, and defector in a rock-paper-scissors dynamics.ConclusionsThese findings highlight the importance of behavioral heterogeneity in stabilizing the population structure and provide a potential reasonable explanation for the maintenance and evolution of cooperation in microbial communities.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12915-019-0639-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Quorum sensing provides a molecular mechanism for evolution to tune and maintain investment in cooperation

“…We predicted that defectors would be less likely to evolve and rise to detectable frequencies in WT populations due to our previous competition results, as well as other reported mechanisms of cheater control such policing and metabolic constraint [15,[60][61][62][63][64]. We found that this prediction was partially correct in the conditions tested.…”

Bacterial Community Interactions During Chronic Respiratory Disease

“…In addition to nutrients, bacteria can also produce extracellular products that benefit neighboring cells. Although an individual cell experiences an energetic cost in metabolism, the production is beneficial for the surrounding population (Zhao et al, 2019). The production of these products occurs when bacteria are in a dense biofilm community where many of the surrounding cells are related organisms.…”

Coexistence of Microbial Species in Structured Communities by Forming a Hawk-Dove Game Like Interactive Relationship

“…WT PAO1 or lasR mutant strains were well-mixed with K. pneumoniae at different ratios (1:99, 1:1, and 99:1) in 1.0 ml of sterile saline solution. Subsequently, 5 μl of inocula were separately spotted on disposable sterile petri dishes containing 20 ml of LB agar medium or modified M9 agar medium supplemented with 0.5% (w/v) of skim milk powder (Zhao et al, 2019). The plates were sealed by sealing films and then statically cultured at 37°C for different time periods.…”