“…Volcanic and smoke particles show rather different chemical, physical, and morphological properties. In contrast to liquid, spherical, less light-absorbing sulfuric acid droplets of volcanic origin, stratospheric smoke particles from the wildfires in 2017 were observed to be nonspherical Hu et al, 2019) and probably consisted of a solid core (black carbon (BC) aggregate) with nonspherical organic coating (Yu et al, 2019). In contrast to volcanic sulfuric acid particles, soot particles significantly absorb solar radiation (a direct effect on climate) and also influence the evolution of cirrus clouds by serving as INPs in heterogeneous ice nucleation processes (an indirect effect) (Hoose and Möhler, 2012;Kanji et al, 2017;Ullrich et al, 2017), unlike liquid sulfuric acid droplets which influence cirrus occurrence and evolution via homogeneous ice nucleation (Jensen and Toon, 1992;Sassen et al, 1995;Liu and Penner, 2002;Campbell et al, 2012).…”