Audience segmentation and climate change communication: conceptual and methodological considerations

Abstract

Engaging the public about mitigating or adapting to climate change threats poses significant challenges for scientists, policy makers, and others responsible for developing communication strategies. In response to these challenges, interest is growing in audience segmentation as a possible strategy to develop more effective communications that are tailored and targeted to subgroups of the public who share similar values, beliefs, behaviors, and/or policy preferences about climate change. In this article, we provide a brief historical overview of audience segmentation and its applications to marketing, health, politics, and most recently climate change. We then critically evaluate several conceptual arguments about whether segmentation is an appropriate strategy for climate change communications, review key methodological considerations associated with conducting segmentation analyses, and make several recommendations about best practice. We conclude that, in principle, audience segmentation and targeted messaging are potentially valuable tools for enhancing climate change communication. But, in practice, there are conceptual and methodological complexities of which practitioners and consumers should be aware when conducting and interpreting the results of segmentation studies. In addition, more research is required, particularly related to tailoring and targeting messages to identified segments, before these strategies can be considered to have a sufficient evidence base to warrant widespread adoption. This article is categorized under: Perceptions, Behavior, and Communication of Climate Change > Perceptions of Climate Change

Communicating Climate Change: A Qualitative Study Exploring how Communicators and Educators are Approaching Climate-Change Discussions

“…Different values between groups also means that efforts to satisfy one group's needs through climate policies can create conflict amongst those groups (O'Brien & Wolf). In response to these challenges, audience segmentation has been suggested as a possible strategy to develop effective communications that are targeted to specific groups within the public who share similar values, beliefs, behaviors, and/or policy preferences about climate change (Hine et al, 2014). One strength of audience segmentation and framing is that people respond and pay closer attention to persuasive messages that match attitudes and behavior (Fujita, Eyal, & Chaiken, 2008).…”

Pacific Islanders’ understanding of climate change: Where do they source information and to what extent do they trust it?

“…On the basis of country of origin, gender, year, and faculty of study, the sample is broadly representative of the student body at USP in 2013 when the survey was conducted . Most questions paralleled those in similar surveys to facilitate inter-sample comparisons (Hine et al 2014;Hmielowski et al 2014;Leiserowitz et al 2015).…”

“…Notwithstanding this limitation, as would be expected, more senior students have seen more television programmes about climate change and read more materials produced by regional agencies on the topic (see Table S2). In addition, it is not simply a matter of identifying the best channels for reaching different audiences, but also crafting messages that resonate with those audiences (Hine et al 2014.…”

Using behavioural science to improve Australia’s environmental regulation

“…In the Internet age, online advertisements can be precisely targeted to individuals, based on their search histories and social media habits (O'Neil 2016). Such sophisticated methods have not permeated environmental governance to any great degree, although recently has been some movement in this general direction (Hine et al 2014). In this research we investigated the potential utility of techniques that might be more familiarly found in commercial marketing to support the achievement of legal land stewardship obligations: statistical analyses to segment the market; and 'gamification' of consumer decisions to identify what stimuli are most likely to trigger desired behaviours in the identified 'market' segments.…”