2022
|
Sign up to set email alerts
Asymmetrical sex reversal: Does the type of heterogamety predict propensity for sex reversal?
Abstract: Sex reversal, a mismatch between phenotypic and genetic sex, can be induced by chemical and thermal insults in ectotherms. Therefore, climate change and environmental pollution may increase sex-reversal frequency in wild populations, with wide-ranging implications for sex ratios, population dynamics, and the evolution of sex determination. We propose that reconsidering the half-century old theory "Witschi's rule" should facilitate understanding the differences between species in sex-reversal propensity and the… Show more
View preprint versions
Search citation statements
Order By: Relevance
Paper Sections
Select...
12
8
5
1
Citation Types
1
43
0
0
Year Published
Range
2023
20232026
2026Publication Types
Select...
15
4
1
Relationship
9
11
Authors
Journals
Cited by 20 publications
(44 citation statements)
References 101 publications
1
43
0
0
Order By: Relevance
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…In two of these instances, the ovotestes occurred in the heterogametic sex, which cannot be associated with sex reversal. The development of ovotestes in XY individuals, rather than complete sex reversal, is consistent with theoretical predictions that sex reversal should be rarer in the heterogametic sex [23]. The underlying cause for the development of ovotestes in these individuals is unclear.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 79%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…In two of these instances, the ovotestes occurred in the heterogametic sex, which cannot be associated with sex reversal. The development of ovotestes in XY individuals, rather than complete sex reversal, is consistent with theoretical predictions that sex reversal should be rarer in the heterogametic sex [23]. The underlying cause for the development of ovotestes in these individuals is unclear.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 79%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Moreover, various studies assessing TRN applied only a limited number of incubation temperatures and made conclusions on limited sample sizes (see ‘TSD_note’ in HerpSexDet (Nemesházi and Bókony 2023) and see also Ospina‐Álvarez and Piferrer 2008). In such studies it is difficult to infer if sex‐ratio bias was caused by sex reversal or sex‐biased mortality, which is a common methodological constraint (Nemesházi and Bókony 2022). We suspect that these limitations are largely responsible for the significant lack of fundamental empirical information regarding the potential temperature‐sensitivity of sexual development under GSD.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Besides conducting laboratory experiments, it is important to uncover sex-reversal frequencies in wild populations as well, by comparing the genotypic sex with the phenotypic sex in each captured individual (Dissanayake, Holleley, Deakin, et al 2021;Holleley et al 2015;Nemesházi et al 2020; see further reports in Nemesházi and Bókony 2023). Such studies should account for the possibility that certain chemical pollutants may also induce sex reversal (see examples in Nemesházi and Bókony 2022). Collecting such empirical data is crucial for understanding how and to what extent environmental conditions influence the evolution of sex determination and its consequences for demography and population persistence.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…2020; see further reports in Nemesházi and Bókony 2023). Such studies should account for the possibility that certain chemical pollutants may also induce sex reversal (see examples in Nemesházi and Bókony 2022). Collecting such empirical data is crucial for understanding how and to what extent environmental conditions influence the evolution of sex determination and its consequences for demography and population persistence.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Second, the direction of sex reversal we observed in the Spanish Bd treatment (i.e., female to male) is unexpected because the common toad has a ZZ/ZW sex chromosome system. According to the theory of asymmetrical sex reversal and scant empirical data, the homogametic sex is more prone to undergo sex reversal (Nemesházi & Bókony, 2022 ); thus, in common toads, ZZ females are more likely than ZW males. The single ZZ female we detected in the control group might be due to this higher propensity of sex reversal in the ZZ genotype, possibly in response to early‐life stressors experienced before we captured the tadpoles for our study.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…In two of these instances, the ovotestes occurred in the heterogametic sex, which cannot be associated with sex reversal. The development of ovotestes in XY individuals, rather than complete sex reversal, is consistent with theoretical predictions that sex reversal should be rarer in the heterogametic sex [23]. The underlying cause for the development of ovotestes in these individuals is unclear.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 79%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Moreover, various studies assessing TRN applied only a limited number of incubation temperatures and made conclusions on limited sample sizes (see ‘TSD_note’ in HerpSexDet (Nemesházi and Bókony 2023) and see also Ospina‐Álvarez and Piferrer 2008). In such studies it is difficult to infer if sex‐ratio bias was caused by sex reversal or sex‐biased mortality, which is a common methodological constraint (Nemesházi and Bókony 2022). We suspect that these limitations are largely responsible for the significant lack of fundamental empirical information regarding the potential temperature‐sensitivity of sexual development under GSD.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Besides conducting laboratory experiments, it is important to uncover sex-reversal frequencies in wild populations as well, by comparing the genotypic sex with the phenotypic sex in each captured individual (Dissanayake, Holleley, Deakin, et al 2021;Holleley et al 2015;Nemesházi et al 2020; see further reports in Nemesházi and Bókony 2023). Such studies should account for the possibility that certain chemical pollutants may also induce sex reversal (see examples in Nemesházi and Bókony 2022). Collecting such empirical data is crucial for understanding how and to what extent environmental conditions influence the evolution of sex determination and its consequences for demography and population persistence.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…2020; see further reports in Nemesházi and Bókony 2023). Such studies should account for the possibility that certain chemical pollutants may also induce sex reversal (see examples in Nemesházi and Bókony 2022). Collecting such empirical data is crucial for understanding how and to what extent environmental conditions influence the evolution of sex determination and its consequences for demography and population persistence.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Second, the direction of sex reversal we observed in the Spanish Bd treatment (i.e., female to male) is unexpected because the common toad has a ZZ/ZW sex chromosome system. According to the theory of asymmetrical sex reversal and scant empirical data, the homogametic sex is more prone to undergo sex reversal (Nemesházi & Bókony, 2022 ); thus, in common toads, ZZ females are more likely than ZW males. The single ZZ female we detected in the control group might be due to this higher propensity of sex reversal in the ZZ genotype, possibly in response to early‐life stressors experienced before we captured the tadpoles for our study.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…In two of these instances, the ovotestes occurred in the heterogametic sex, which cannot be associated with sex reversal. The development of ovotestes in XY individuals, rather than complete sex reversal, is consistent with theoretical predictions that sex reversal should be rarer in the heterogametic sex [23]. The underlying cause for the development of ovotestes in these individuals is unclear.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 79%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Moreover, various studies assessing TRN applied only a limited number of incubation temperatures and made conclusions on limited sample sizes (see ‘TSD_note’ in HerpSexDet (Nemesházi and Bókony 2023) and see also Ospina‐Álvarez and Piferrer 2008). In such studies it is difficult to infer if sex‐ratio bias was caused by sex reversal or sex‐biased mortality, which is a common methodological constraint (Nemesházi and Bókony 2022). We suspect that these limitations are largely responsible for the significant lack of fundamental empirical information regarding the potential temperature‐sensitivity of sexual development under GSD.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Besides conducting laboratory experiments, it is important to uncover sex-reversal frequencies in wild populations as well, by comparing the genotypic sex with the phenotypic sex in each captured individual (Dissanayake, Holleley, Deakin, et al 2021;Holleley et al 2015;Nemesházi et al 2020; see further reports in Nemesházi and Bókony 2023). Such studies should account for the possibility that certain chemical pollutants may also induce sex reversal (see examples in Nemesházi and Bókony 2022). Collecting such empirical data is crucial for understanding how and to what extent environmental conditions influence the evolution of sex determination and its consequences for demography and population persistence.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…2020; see further reports in Nemesházi and Bókony 2023). Such studies should account for the possibility that certain chemical pollutants may also induce sex reversal (see examples in Nemesházi and Bókony 2022). Collecting such empirical data is crucial for understanding how and to what extent environmental conditions influence the evolution of sex determination and its consequences for demography and population persistence.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Second, the direction of sex reversal we observed in the Spanish Bd treatment (i.e., female to male) is unexpected because the common toad has a ZZ/ZW sex chromosome system. According to the theory of asymmetrical sex reversal and scant empirical data, the homogametic sex is more prone to undergo sex reversal (Nemesházi & Bókony, 2022 ); thus, in common toads, ZZ females are more likely than ZW males. The single ZZ female we detected in the control group might be due to this higher propensity of sex reversal in the ZZ genotype, possibly in response to early‐life stressors experienced before we captured the tadpoles for our study.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract