Association Between American Board of Surgery Initial Certification and Risk of Receiving Severe Disciplinary Actions Against Medical Licenses

Abstract

IMPORTANCE Board certification is used as a marker of surgeon quality and professionalism. Although some research has linked certification in surgery to outcomes, more research is needed.OBJECTIVE To measure associations between surgeons obtaining American Board of Surgery (ABS) certification and examination performance with receiving future severe disciplinary actions against their medical licenses.DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS Retrospective analysis of severe license action rates for surgeons who attempted ABS certification based on certification status and examination performance. Surgeons who attempted to become certified were classified as certified or failing to obtain certification. Additionally, groups were further categorized based on whether the surgeon had to repeat examinations and whether they ultimately passed. The study included surgeons who initially attempted certification between 1976 and 2017 (n = 44 290). Severe license actions from 1976 to 2018 were obtained from the Federation of State Medical Boards, and certification data were obtained from the ABS database. Data were analyzed between 1978 and 2008.MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Severe license action rates were analyzed across certified surgeons and those failing to obtain certification, as well as across examination performance groups. RESULTSThe final dataset included 36 197 men (81.7%) and 8093 women (18.3%). The incidence of severe license actions was significantly greater for surgeons who attempted and failed to obtain certification (incidence rate per 1000 person-years = 2.49; 95% CI, 2.13-2.85) than surgeons who were certified (incidence rate per 1000 person years = 0.77; 95% CI, 0.71-0.83). Adjusting for sex and international medical graduate status, the risk of receiving a severe license action across time was also significantly greater for surgeons who failed to obtain certification. Surgeons who progressed further in the certification examination sequence and had fewer repeated examinations had a lower incidence and less risk over time of receiving severe license actions. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCEObtaining board certification was associated with a lower rate of receiving severe license actions from a state medical board. Passing examinations in the certification examination process on the first attempt was also associated with lower severe license action rates. This study provides supporting evidence that board certification is 1 marker of surgeon quality and professionalism.

Associations between initial American Board of Internal Medicine certification and maintenance of certification status of attending physicians and in-hospital mortality of patients with acute myocardial infarction or congestive heart failure: a retrospective cohort study of hospitalisations in Pennsylvania, USA

“…Thus, we propose that the mechanism for the associations we found is that physicians with greater medical knowledge and better medical judgement are, as a group, providing better care which results in improved outcomes, including decreased mortality. Our findings are concordant with other studies associating increased medical knowledge with better care as demonstrated by process measures, costs, state medical board disciplinary actions and specifically diagnostic knowledge as measured by MOC with emergency department visits, hospitalisations and death 8–10 15–18 21 32…”

“…In this regard, there is reasonable evidence of a relationship with clinical care. For instance, there are several studies showing that certification is positively associated with the process of care provided to patients and their outcomes, while being negatively associated with disciplinary actions by state licensing boards 6–10. One aim of this study is to gather additional validity evidence based on the association between initial certification and patient outcomes.…”

An Online, Modular Curriculum Enhances Surgical Education and Improves Learning Outcomes in East, Central, and Southern Africa: A Mixed-Methods Study

“…Participation in the modular curriculum thus represents an effective learning strategy. Passing certification examinations is a marker of surgeon quality and professionalism, 26 and a curriculum that improves passage rates is an important contribution to surgical education and quality.…”

Demographic and Comorbidities Data Description of Population in Mexico with SARS-CoV-2 Infected Patients(COVID19): An Online Tool Analysis

“…A cumulative incidence plot shows the proportion of incidence of subjects with a particular condition over time. The curves presented in this graph disclose the behavior of the proportion of these subjects [ 21 ].…”