An Economic Evaluation of Resistance Training and Aerobic Training versus Balance and Toning Exercises in Older Adults with Mild Cognitive Impairment

Abstract

BackgroundMild cognitive impairment (MCI) represents a critical window to intervene against dementia. Exercise training is a promising intervention strategy, but the efficiency (i.e., relationship of costs and consequences) of such types of training remains unknown. Thus, we estimated the incremental cost-effectiveness of resistance training or aerobic training compared with balance and tone exercises in terms of changes in executive cognitive function among senior women with probable MCI.MethodsEconomic evaluation conducted concurrently with a six-month three arm randomized controlled trial including eighty-six community dwelling women aged 70 to 80 years living in Vancouver, Canada. Participants received twice-weekly resistance training (n = 28), twice weekly aerobic training (n = 30) or twice-weekly balance and tone (control group) classes (n = 28) for 6 months. The primary outcome measure of the Exercise for Cognition and Everyday Living (EXCEL) study assessed executive cognitive function, a test of selective attention and conflict resolution (i.e., Stroop Test). We collected healthcare resource utilization costs over six months.ResultsBased on the bootstrapped estimates from our base case analysis, we found that both the aerobic training and resistance training interventions were less costly than twice weekly balance and tone classes. Compared with the balance and tone group, the resistance-training group had significantly improved performance on the Stroop Test (p = 0.04).ConclusionsResistance training and aerobic training result in health care cost saving and are more effective than balance and tone classes after only 6 months of intervention. Resistance training is a promising strategy to alter the trajectory of cognitive decline in seniors with MCI.Trial RegistrationClinicalTrials.gov NCT00958867.

Effects of dual-task training on balance and executive functions in Parkinson's disease: A pilot study

“…Baker et al 2010;Mirelman et al 2011;Davis et al 2013;Tabak et al 2013). Our research has demonstrated that in a cognitive-motor dual-task training program with 12 sessions, the dual-task training was only statistically more effective than the single-task training for the COPx with eyes closed.…”

Choice of Outcome Measure in an Economic Evaluation: A Potential Role for the Capability Approach

“…Aside from Makai et al [39] and Henderson et al [54], no other economic evaluation employing an ICECAP measure has to date produced an ICER with respect to the measure. This is likely to be due to the measure being new and unfamiliar to decision makers, so the evaluation team has used EQ-5D/ QALYs (as Henderson et al [54] do) or a clinical measure [55]. Of course, 15 years ago we did not have an explicit cost-effectiveness threshold for the QALY 9 ; something similar may come with time, however, it could be further complicated by the fact that the measure is broader than health so it may additionally be necessary to estimate the opportunity cost from a budget that is wider than the health budget.…”

The effect of exercise intervention on cognitive performance in persons at risk of, or with, dementia: A systematic review and meta-analysis

“…Table 1. A list of excluded studies [32,[41][42][43][44][45][46][47][48][49][50][51][52][53][54][55][56][57][58][59][60] can be also found in Suppl. Table 2.…”