2022
|
Sign up to set email alerts
A Troubled Body of Knowledge: The Durability of Racial Science in Human Anatomy Research in South Africa
Abstract: This article examines the durability of racial science in the field of anatomy at one of South Africa's oldest universities and its resonance with race essentialist research in other national and transnational contexts. We present a critical assessment of more than 70 published and unpublished papers in anatomy through the lens of the politics of knowledge; in this perspective, scientific knowledge is viewed as socially constructed, value-laden, and acting in the service of power. The study finds that racial s… Show more
Search citation statements
Order By: Relevance
Paper Sections
Select...
31
2
2
0
Citation Types
1
19
0
0
Year Published
Range
2023
20232026
2026Publication Types
Select...
16
14
1
1
Relationship
0
32
Authors
Journals
Cited by 32 publications
(20 citation statements)
References 49 publications
1
19
0
0
Order By: Relevance
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…1 ). Our results highlight the challenge detecting population-level differences between Mixed and African population-affinities as both are primarily descendants from Africa with past and present admixture, which is supported by other research showing morphological and biological similarity [ 4 , 20 , 56 , 57 , 59 , 60 , 93 , 94 , [96] , [97] , [98] , [99] , [100] , [101] , [102] , [103] , [104] , 116 , 117 ]. On the other hand, the comparison of social race categories is also flawed and does not indicate the accuracy of anthropological population-affinity estimations, as an individual could socially/legally identify as a particular group, however, their skeletal morphology may reflect other aspects of their population-affinity.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 84%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…1 ). Our results highlight the challenge detecting population-level differences between Mixed and African population-affinities as both are primarily descendants from Africa with past and present admixture, which is supported by other research showing morphological and biological similarity [ 4 , 20 , 56 , 57 , 59 , 60 , 93 , 94 , [96] , [97] , [98] , [99] , [100] , [101] , [102] , [103] , [104] , 116 , 117 ]. On the other hand, the comparison of social race categories is also flawed and does not indicate the accuracy of anthropological population-affinity estimations, as an individual could socially/legally identify as a particular group, however, their skeletal morphology may reflect other aspects of their population-affinity.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 84%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Established in the 1900s 67 and inspired by skeletal collections of the era, 44,60,104 South African DHOCs are representative of the global unethical practice of using unclaimed individuals for teaching and research in anatomy 9,24–25 . Along with the unethical practice of sourcing bodies without consent, a reliance on unclaimed individuals raises concerns on the perpetuation of structural inequality and the exploitation of marginalized populations 2,105–106 who had little legal or social protections 7,36 .…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Along with the unethical practice of sourcing bodies without consent, a reliance on unclaimed individuals raises concerns on the perpetuation of structural inequality and the exploitation of marginalized populations 2,105–106 who had little legal or social protections 7,36 . Provenance of the bodies and skeletons in 20th century South Africa depended heavily on the marginalized 13,44 . In the future, there is a need for South African institutions to address mechanisms for redressing these unethical practices, such as the Human Remains Management Project (2016), 107 which promotes policy development, community consultation, research, training, and exhibitions to guide the ethical management and repatriation of human remains in southern Africa.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Body donation among Black and Coloured South Africans may also be hindered by historical colonial injustices during Apartheid, 100 , 101 such as the use of unclaimed Black and Coloured bodies for teaching and colonial practices 44 , 61 while excluding Black and Coloured students from the dissection of White bodies. 44 , 100 Human skeletal remains were historically collected to reinforce colonial ideologies of racial hierarchy, and their continued retention without redress risks perpetuating these injustices today.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Body donation among Black and Coloured South Africans may also be hindered by historical colonial injustices during Apartheid, 100 , 101 such as the use of unclaimed Black and Coloured bodies for teaching and colonial practices 44 , 61 while excluding Black and Coloured students from the dissection of White bodies. 44 , 100 Human skeletal remains were historically collected to reinforce colonial ideologies of racial hierarchy, and their continued retention without redress risks perpetuating these injustices today. 43 , 44 , 70 These discriminatory practices, combined with the broader context of racial violence and political disappearances of individuals during Apartheid, 102 have likely contributed to mistrust toward academic and scientific institutions in South Africa.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…1 ). Our results highlight the challenge detecting population-level differences between Mixed and African population-affinities as both are primarily descendants from Africa with past and present admixture, which is supported by other research showing morphological and biological similarity [ 4 , 20 , 56 , 57 , 59 , 60 , 93 , 94 , [96] , [97] , [98] , [99] , [100] , [101] , [102] , [103] , [104] , 116 , 117 ]. On the other hand, the comparison of social race categories is also flawed and does not indicate the accuracy of anthropological population-affinity estimations, as an individual could socially/legally identify as a particular group, however, their skeletal morphology may reflect other aspects of their population-affinity.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 84%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Established in the 1900s 67 and inspired by skeletal collections of the era, 44,60,104 South African DHOCs are representative of the global unethical practice of using unclaimed individuals for teaching and research in anatomy 9,24–25 . Along with the unethical practice of sourcing bodies without consent, a reliance on unclaimed individuals raises concerns on the perpetuation of structural inequality and the exploitation of marginalized populations 2,105–106 who had little legal or social protections 7,36 .…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Along with the unethical practice of sourcing bodies without consent, a reliance on unclaimed individuals raises concerns on the perpetuation of structural inequality and the exploitation of marginalized populations 2,105–106 who had little legal or social protections 7,36 . Provenance of the bodies and skeletons in 20th century South Africa depended heavily on the marginalized 13,44 . In the future, there is a need for South African institutions to address mechanisms for redressing these unethical practices, such as the Human Remains Management Project (2016), 107 which promotes policy development, community consultation, research, training, and exhibitions to guide the ethical management and repatriation of human remains in southern Africa.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Body donation among Black and Coloured South Africans may also be hindered by historical colonial injustices during Apartheid, 100 , 101 such as the use of unclaimed Black and Coloured bodies for teaching and colonial practices 44 , 61 while excluding Black and Coloured students from the dissection of White bodies. 44 , 100 Human skeletal remains were historically collected to reinforce colonial ideologies of racial hierarchy, and their continued retention without redress risks perpetuating these injustices today.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Body donation among Black and Coloured South Africans may also be hindered by historical colonial injustices during Apartheid, 100 , 101 such as the use of unclaimed Black and Coloured bodies for teaching and colonial practices 44 , 61 while excluding Black and Coloured students from the dissection of White bodies. 44 , 100 Human skeletal remains were historically collected to reinforce colonial ideologies of racial hierarchy, and their continued retention without redress risks perpetuating these injustices today. 43 , 44 , 70 These discriminatory practices, combined with the broader context of racial violence and political disappearances of individuals during Apartheid, 102 have likely contributed to mistrust toward academic and scientific institutions in South Africa.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…1 ). Our results highlight the challenge detecting population-level differences between Mixed and African population-affinities as both are primarily descendants from Africa with past and present admixture, which is supported by other research showing morphological and biological similarity [ 4 , 20 , 56 , 57 , 59 , 60 , 93 , 94 , [96] , [97] , [98] , [99] , [100] , [101] , [102] , [103] , [104] , 116 , 117 ]. On the other hand, the comparison of social race categories is also flawed and does not indicate the accuracy of anthropological population-affinity estimations, as an individual could socially/legally identify as a particular group, however, their skeletal morphology may reflect other aspects of their population-affinity.…”
Section: Discussion
supporting
confidence: 84%
Smart CitationsHow the paper below cites the one you are viewing
“…Established in the 1900s 67 and inspired by skeletal collections of the era, 44,60,104 South African DHOCs are representative of the global unethical practice of using unclaimed individuals for teaching and research in anatomy 9,24–25 . Along with the unethical practice of sourcing bodies without consent, a reliance on unclaimed individuals raises concerns on the perpetuation of structural inequality and the exploitation of marginalized populations 2,105–106 who had little legal or social protections 7,36 .…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Along with the unethical practice of sourcing bodies without consent, a reliance on unclaimed individuals raises concerns on the perpetuation of structural inequality and the exploitation of marginalized populations 2,105–106 who had little legal or social protections 7,36 . Provenance of the bodies and skeletons in 20th century South Africa depended heavily on the marginalized 13,44 . In the future, there is a need for South African institutions to address mechanisms for redressing these unethical practices, such as the Human Remains Management Project (2016), 107 which promotes policy development, community consultation, research, training, and exhibitions to guide the ethical management and repatriation of human remains in southern Africa.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Body donation among Black and Coloured South Africans may also be hindered by historical colonial injustices during Apartheid, 100 , 101 such as the use of unclaimed Black and Coloured bodies for teaching and colonial practices 44 , 61 while excluding Black and Coloured students from the dissection of White bodies. 44 , 100 Human skeletal remains were historically collected to reinforce colonial ideologies of racial hierarchy, and their continued retention without redress risks perpetuating these injustices today.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Body donation among Black and Coloured South Africans may also be hindered by historical colonial injustices during Apartheid, 100 , 101 such as the use of unclaimed Black and Coloured bodies for teaching and colonial practices 44 , 61 while excluding Black and Coloured students from the dissection of White bodies. 44 , 100 Human skeletal remains were historically collected to reinforce colonial ideologies of racial hierarchy, and their continued retention without redress risks perpetuating these injustices today. 43 , 44 , 70 These discriminatory practices, combined with the broader context of racial violence and political disappearances of individuals during Apartheid, 102 have likely contributed to mistrust toward academic and scientific institutions in South Africa.…”
Section: Discussion
mentioning
confidence: 99%
Abstract