A Sagittal Patellar Angle Linear Equation Reflecting Patellofemoral Kinematics: Evaluation of Patellar Height at any Degree of Knee Flexion Angle

Abstract

Objective: To confirm whether a novel sagittal patellar angle linear equation used for evaluating patellar height by calculating expected sagittal patellar angle (SPA) at any degree of knee flexion angle is suitable for patients older than 17 years and its reliability compared with other commonly used methods. Methods:From September 2016 to September 2019, a total number of 202 consecutive outpatients' knee lateral X-ray radiographs were retrospectively measured and evaluated using a recently proposed linear equation Y = 1.94 + 0.74 Â knee flexion(KF) angle. Patients were divided by ages into ayounger group, whose ages were between 17-49 years, and an older group, whose ages were older than 49 years, which has not been validated in the original study. Parameters such as KF, SPA, patella and patella tendon length and so on were measured on computer with picture archiving and communication system by two independent observers at an interval of 1 month. Insall-Salvati (IS) index, Caton-Deschamps (CD) index and Y value, correlation coefficients were calculated and compared using SPSS 22.0 software. Results:In the younger group, 143 patients (165 knees) were included, ages were 17-49 (31.62 AE 11.38) years, males/females were 70 (48.95%)/73 (51.05%), left knees/right knees were 83 (50.30%)/82 (49.70%), mean value of Y was 31.50 AE 10.07 , and SPA was 34.38 AE 12.38 , mean value of IS was 1.06 AE 0.17, mean value of CD was 1.04 AE 0.18. While in older group, 59 patients (78 knees) were included, ages were 50-60 (mean 54.61 AE 2.99) years, there were 32 males (54.24%) and 27 females (45.76%), 42 knees were left (53.85%) and 36 knees were right (46.15%), mean values of Y and SPA were 25.90 AE 11.55 and 29.36 AE 14.22 , mean IS index in older group was 1.06 AE 0.18, mean CD index was 1.00 AE 0.16. Intra-and inter-observer reliabilities of Y in younger and older groups were 0.999, 0.999, 1.000 and 0.999, meaning high reliability and reproducibility, but low Pearson's correlation coefficients with IS and CD index were showed as À0.213 and À 0.216 in younger group and À 0.113 and À 0.316 in older group. Conclusions:In patients older than 17 years, the linear equation Y = 1.94 + 0.74 Â KF is a reliable and practical method to evaluate SPA regardless of age and knee flexion angle, but has weak correlation coefficients with the IS and CD index.

Ispitivanje pouzdanosti primjene pet različitih metoda mjerenja visine patele na profilnom radiogramu koljena

“…Snimanja su izvršena na digitalnom detektoru veličine 24 x 30 uz udaljenost rendgenske cijevi od 115 cm 8 . Veličina dobivenog kuta fleksije koljena na profilnim radiogramima izmjerena je na sjecištu tangenti stražnjeg korteksa femura i tibije (Slika 1) 9 . Na svakom profilnom radiogramu koljena pojedinog ispitanika izmjerena je visina patele pomoću pet različitih metoda mjerenja: 1.…”

“…Insall Visina patele određivana je mjerenjem položaja patele na profilnim radiogramima u ležećem položaju ispitanika. Prosječan kut fleksije koljena kod ispitanika u ovom istraživanju bio je 36,57° (30 -40°), čime je izbjegnut mogući utjecaj fleksije na izmjerene vrijednosti visine patele 9,15 . Također, snimanjem profilnih radiograma koljena u ležećem položaju izbjegnut je utjecaj kontrakcije mišića kvadricepsa na visinu patele.…”