A prospective risk assessment of informal carers’ medication administration errors within the domiciliary setting

Abstract

Increasingly, medication is being administered at home by family and friends of the care-recipient. This study aims to identify and analyse risks associated with potential drug administration errors made by informal carers at home. We mapped medication administration at home with a multidisciplinary team that included carers, health care professionals and patients. Evidence-based risk-analysis methodologies were applied: Healthcare Failure Modes and Effect Analysis (HFMEA), Systematic Human Error Reduction and Prediction Analysis (SHERPA) and Systems-Theoretic Accident Model and Processes (STAMP). The process of administration comprises seven sub-processes. Thirty-four possible failure modes were identified and six of these were rated as high risk. These highlighted that medications may be given with a wrong dose, stored incorrectly, not discontinued as instructed, not recorded, or not ordered on time, and often caused by communication and support problems. Combined risk analyses contributed unique information helpful to better understand the medication administration risks and causes within homecare. Practitioner Summary: Increasingly, medication is being administered at home by family and friends of the care-recipient. This study identifies risks associated with potential drug administration errors made by informal carers at home through consensus-based quantitative techniques. The different analyses contribute unique information helpful to better understand the administration risks and causes.

<p>Risk Management in Executive Levels of Healthcare Organizations: Insights from a Scoping Review (2018)</p>

“…According to the results, there were several methods for outlining risky processes that executive levels of HCOs can use depending on their needs: Textual system description, 8,41,53,59 activity breakdown structure (ABS), 8 radar charts, 34 flow charts, 3,25,28,30,38,45,50,56,62 All organizational processes (clinical and non-clinical processes, technology processes, etc.) 8 Customer perceptions, costs, functions and health status 8…”

On the application of Human Reliability Analysis in healthcare: Opportunities and challenges

“…There are a small number of studies that describe the application of popular HRA techniques such as SHERPA (Systematic Human Error Reduction and Predication Approach) [26], HEART, SPAR-H and CREAM in healthcare. SHERPA has been used to identify human errors in anaesthesia [27], and to analyse drug prescription and administration in hospital, primary care and community settings [28][29][30]. While HRA techniques are usually used to predict performance of well-trained professionals, a study that sought to understand and improve the ability of stroke patients to deal with everyday tasks (e.g.…”

Health and social care ergonomics: patient safety in practice

“…We are seeing a continued focus on medication management research from two papers in 2006 (Fogarty and Mckeon 2006;Hellier et al 2006) looking at medication labelling (packaging) and the organisational climate for medication administration to four papers in 2017 looking at the design of integrated systems (including information technology) across healthcare sectors (Jahn and Caldwell 2017;Jun et al 2017), and medication adherence in home (informal) care settings (Mickelson and Holden 2017;Parand et al 2017). As with the surgical papers, the use of a systems approach is more evident in 2017 with, for example, Mickelson and Holden (2017) describing performance shaping factors of the person or team, task, tools and technologies within the organisational, physical, and social context in a Patient Work System Model.…”

“…In 2006 there were 6 papers discussing 'the problem' from error detection, identification and reporting (Carayon et al 2006;Kanse et al 2006;Nyssen and Blavier 2006), to investigation (Catchpole et al 2006;Dieckmann et al 2006) and description (Kostopoulou 2006). In 2017, two papers discuss 'the problem' , Parand et al (2017) and Reader, Reddy, and Brett (2017). Parand et al (2017) take a prospective (rather than retrospective) approach using 3 well-established ergonomic risk analysis techniques Healthcare Failure Modes and Effect Analysis (HFMEA), Systematic Human Error Reduction and Prediction Analysis (SHERPA) and Systems-Theoretic the delivery of effective, high quality and safe health care identified by healthcare staff.…”

“…In 2017, two papers discuss 'the problem' , Parand et al (2017) and Reader, Reddy, and Brett (2017). Parand et al (2017) take a prospective (rather than retrospective) approach using 3 well-established ergonomic risk analysis techniques Healthcare Failure Modes and Effect Analysis (HFMEA), Systematic Human Error Reduction and Prediction Analysis (SHERPA) and Systems-Theoretic the delivery of effective, high quality and safe health care identified by healthcare staff. Some problems are well known (staff shortages, finance and patient complexity), but others, they suggest, raise questions about healthcare commitment to patient and staff safety.…”